The federal government needs to do a lot more to tackle the long-term drinking water crisis on First Nations reserves.
That was the main message delivered by Auditor General, Karen Hogan, in the report she released the other day on the state of safe drinking water in First Nations reserves.
According to Hogan and her team at the Office of the Auditor General of Canada, long-term drinking water advisories are a fixture on many reserves (sixty to be specific, in forty-one different First Nations communities) and will tragically remain so for years to come, all because of the inadequate support provided by Indigenous Services Canada.
As a result, thousands of First Nations lack water clean enough to safely drink, let alone even bathe in, and live in conditions one would expect to find in the Global South. Not in a wealthy G7 country.
Without question, the report and its findings were a damning indictment of both Justin Trudeau, and the Liberal government he heads.
Unlike other issues, in which Trudeau has attempted to absolve himself of culpability by shouldering blame onto his Conservative predecessor, this one sticks entirely to him.
He, out of his own volition, made the promise to First Nations people to eliminate all long-term water advisories by March of this year. No one tied his hands or forced him to.
But he did it all the same and gave himself a full five years to fulfill his pledge.
Yet here we are, a half a decade later, and dozens of long-term water advisories remain in place on countless reserves.
True, the government has not been sitting idly by, doing nothing as First Nations peoples have continued their decades-long struggle to access and retain safe drinking water.
In the five-and-a-half years that Trudeau has been Prime Minister, the federal Liberals have spent approximately $1.79 billion on water and wastewater projects, with an additional $1.5 billion more announced last fall. Using these funds, the Liberal government has helped lift one hundred long-term water advisories across the country: a not insignificant number.
However, as Hogan's report notes, even these improvements are far less impressive after considering the shoddy job the Liberals did in addressing First Nations' water systems.
For instance, several of the advisories that the Liberal government did help lift came back under notice within a matter of months.
The reason being?
The government unwisely chose not to address the underlying reasons behind an advisory, and prioritized the application of short-term fixes, instead of implementing necessary, long-term policy solutions for improved water systems.
To call this a faulty strategy for success would be an understatement.
As Hogan herself has stated, relying on short-term fixes, like the trucking in of clean water for remote communities, is not feasible, nor is it viable it "just takes the problem and pushes it further down the road."
Further hindering progress is the government's outdated funding formula for lifting water advisories, along with its embarrassing lack of regulatory standards for water systems on First Nation reserves.
Of course, the government has tried to defend its poor record and failed timeline to uplift all long-term water advisories.
Unable to blame the Harper Conservatives with this one, the government instead found a different scapegoat to lay its woes upon: the COVID-19 pandemic.
But while in some cases the pandemic has slowed down government delivery of some water system projects, Hogan made clear that many "were already experiencing delays prior to the start of the pandemic."
Evidently, the Liberals have a lot to answer for when it comes to their failure to lift long-term water advisories and deliver clean drinking water to its citizens.
Their record on this issue is a heavily flawed one, with real world implications for the thousands of First Nations people in need.
Come election time whenever that may be voters would do well to remember this failure.
Photo Credit: CBC News