LP_468x60
ontario news watch
on-the-record-468x60-white
and-another-thing-468x60

.single-article-container {
font-family: ‘Courier Prime’, monospace;
}
.single-article-text p {
margin-top: 0;
margin-bottom: 0;
}
.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-7>li:before {
content: “025cb ”
}

.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-6>li:before {
content: “025cf ”
}

.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-5>li:before {
content: “025a0 ”
}

.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-8>li:before {
content: “025a0 ”
}

ul.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-3 {
list-style-type: none
}

ul.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-2 {
list-style-type: none
}

.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-0>li:before {
content: ” ”
}

ul.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-1 {
list-style-type: none
}

ul.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-0 {
list-style-type: none
}

.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-1>li:before {
content: “025cb ”
}

ul.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-7 {
list-style-type: none
}

ul.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-6 {
list-style-type: none
}

ul.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-5 {
list-style-type: none
}

ul.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-4 {
list-style-type: none
}

.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-3>li:before {
content: “025cf ”
}

.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-2>li:before {
content: “025a0 ”
}

.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-4>li:before {
content: “025cb ”
}

ul.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-8 {
list-style-type: none
}

ol {
margin: 0;
padding: 0
}

table td,
table th {
padding: 0
}

.c9 {
margin-left: 36pt;
padding-top: 12pt;
padding-bottom: 12pt;
line-height: 1.0;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: left;
height: 11pt
}

.c3 {
color: #000000;
font-weight: 400;
text-decoration: none;
vertical-align: baseline;
font-size: 12pt;
font-family: ‘Courier Prime’, monospace;
font-style: normal
}

.c4 {
padding-top: 0pt;
padding-bottom: 10pt;
line-height: 1.0;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: center;
height: 11pt
}

.c1 {
color: #000000;
font-weight: 700;
text-decoration: none;
vertical-align: baseline;
font-size: 12pt;
font-family: ‘Courier Prime’, monospace;
font-style: normal
}

.c13 {
color: #000000;
font-weight: 400;
text-decoration: none;
vertical-align: baseline;
font-size: 11pt;
font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif;
font-style: normal
}

.c6 {
margin-left: 36pt !important;
padding-top: 10pt;
padding-bottom: 12pt;
line-height: 1.0;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: left
}

.c10 {
margin-left: 36pt;
padding-top: 12pt;
padding-bottom: 12pt;
line-height: 1.0;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: center
}

.c0 {
margin-left: 12.3pt;
padding-top: 13.6pt;
padding-bottom: 0pt;
line-height: 1.9158997535705566;
text-align: justify;
margin-right: 13.6pt;
height: 11pt
}

.c27 {
color: #000000;
font-weight: 400;
text-decoration: none;
vertical-align: baseline;
font-size: 11pt;
font-family: ‘Courier Prime’, monospace;
font-style: normal
}

.c16 {
padding-top: 12pt;
padding-bottom: 12pt;
line-height: 1.0;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: center
}

.c19 {
-webkit-text-decoration-skip: none;
color: #000000;
text-decoration: underline;
vertical-align: baseline;
text-decoration-skip-ink: none;
font-style: normal
}

.c18 {
padding-top: 0pt;
padding-bottom: 10pt;
line-height: 1.0;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: center
}

.c2 {
padding-top: 10pt;
padding-bottom: 12pt;
line-height: 1.0;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: right
}

.c5 {
padding-top: 10pt;
padding-bottom: 12pt;
line-height: 1.0;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: center
}

.c20 {
padding-top: 12pt;
padding-bottom: 12pt;
line-height: 1.0;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: left
}

.c28 {
padding-top: 0pt;
padding-bottom: 0pt;
line-height: 1.15;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: left
}

.c29 {
padding-top: 0pt;
padding-bottom: 10pt;
line-height: 1.0;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: left
}

.c25 {
padding-top: 12pt;
padding-bottom: 12pt;
line-height: 1.0;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: right
}

.c8 {
padding-top: 10pt;
padding-bottom: 12pt;
line-height: 1.0;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: left
}

.c30 {
padding-top: 0pt;
padding-bottom: 10pt;
line-height: 1.0;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: right
}

.c21 {
color: #000000;
text-decoration: none;
vertical-align: baseline;
font-style: italic
}

.c11 {
font-size: 12pt;
font-family: ‘Courier Prime’, monospace;
font-weight: 700
}

.c15 {
font-size: 12pt;
font-family: ‘Courier Prime’, monospace;
font-weight: 400
}

.c23 {
max-width: 432pt;
padding: 72pt 72pt 72pt 108pt
}

.c24 {
font-style: italic
}

.c7 {
background-color: #ffffff
}

.c12 {
height: 11pt
}

.c14 {
margin-left: 36pt !important
}

.title {
padding-top: 0pt;
color: #000000;
font-size: 26pt;
padding-bottom: 3pt;
font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif;
line-height: 1.15;
page-break-after: avoid;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: left
}

.subtitle {
padding-top: 0pt;
color: #666666;
font-size: 15pt;
padding-bottom: 16pt;
font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif;
line-height: 1.15;
page-break-after: avoid;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: left
}

li {
color: #000000;
font-size: 11pt;
font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif
}

p {
margin: 0;
color: #000000;
font-size: 11pt;
font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif
}

h1 {
padding-top: 20pt;
color: #000000;
font-size: 20pt;
padding-bottom: 6pt;
font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif;
line-height: 1.15;
page-break-after: avoid;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: left
}

h2 {
padding-top: 18pt;
color: #000000;
font-size: 16pt;
padding-bottom: 6pt;
font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif;
line-height: 1.15;
page-break-after: avoid;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: left
}

h3 {
padding-top: 16pt;
color: #434343;
font-size: 14pt;
padding-bottom: 4pt;
font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif;
line-height: 1.15;
page-break-after: avoid;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: left
}

h4 {
padding-top: 14pt;
color: #666666;
font-size: 12pt;
padding-bottom: 4pt;
font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif;
line-height: 1.15;
page-break-after: avoid;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: left
}

h5 {
padding-top: 12pt;
color: #666666;
font-size: 11pt;
padding-bottom: 4pt;
font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif;
line-height: 1.15;
page-break-after: avoid;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: left
}

h6 {
padding-top: 12pt;
color: #666666;
font-size: 11pt;
padding-bottom: 4pt;
font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif;
line-height: 1.15;
page-break-after: avoid;
font-style: italic;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: left
}

CHRISTMAS CRUISE GONE WRONG

Written by:

Shannon Proudfoot

In collaboration with:

Documents filed in the

Southern District of Florida

U.S. Federal Court

* This fictionalized account is based on a lawsuit filed by Sharilyne Anderson and Vera Melnyk. None of the claims have been tested in court.

INTERIOR COZY COTTAGE-LIKE ROOM – NIGHT

FOUR DOE-EYED CHILDREN WEARING PAJAMAS ARE GATHERED AT THE FEET OF A BEARDED ELDERLY MAN CLAD IN RED VELOUR PANTS, A WHITE THERMAL LONG-SLEEVED SHIRT AND SUSPENDERS. A FIREPLACE CRACKLES FESTIVELY IN THE BACKGROUND. THE MAN TURNS TO A BOOKSHELF BESIDE HIS CHAIR AND RETRIEVES A LARGE, LEATHER-BOUND VOLUME WITH GILT-EDGED PAGES. WITH GREAT CARE, HE OPENS ITS COVER AND TURNS BACK TO HIS RAPT AUDIENCE, BECKONING THEM CLOSER.

MAN

Children, tonight I have for you a story about a very special Christmas voyage that did not go at all as planned. This little adventure was supposed to take place in waters as warm and gentle as a hug from Mrs. Claus (he chuckles), but instead it unfolded on the unforgiving blizzard of the high seas. It all began one year ago, in a place that is at once very distant and ever so near to us now: PandemicLand.

SCENE DISSOLVES TO:

INTERIOR LUXURIOUS CONDO – NIGHT

THROUGH THE WINDOWS, A LARGE CITY DUSTED WITH SNOW IS VISIBLE. IN ONE CORNER OF THE ROOM STANDS A TOWERING CHRISTMAS TREE BEDECKED IN RED, GOLD AND BLACK DECORATIONS; AT THE APEX OF THE TREE IS AN ENORMOUS GOLD CENTURION HELMET. A MAN AND WOMAN, EUGENE AND SHARILYNE, RECLINE ON ADJACENT SOFAS. HE IDLY FLIPS TV CHANNELS WHILE SHE THUMBS THROUGH HER PHONE. THERE IS A PALPABLE AIR OF RESTLESSNESS AND ENNUI.

SHARILYNE

I’m sick of being cooped up like this, Eugene. Who knows when this pandemic will end? Can’t we find some way to escape our Canadian isolated existence over the holidays?

EUGENE

(suddenly brightening)

You know, that’s a great idea. We should go somewhere warm, and take our family and friends with us. Hey, what about a Christmas cruise on that yacht charter in the Bahamas that we previously enjoyed?

SHARILYNE

Oh, I love that idea.

EUGENE

I’ll get in touch with the charter broker we dealt with last time.

BRIEF MONTAGE:

EUGENE TAPS RAPIDLY ON HIS PHONE. AT THE RECEIVING END OF THAT MESSAGE, A PHONE PINGS NEXT TO A MAN SITTING IN A TROPICAL ENVIRONMENT, WITH PALM TREES AND OPEN WATER VISIBLE BEHIND HIM. HE READS THE MESSAGE, CLICKS AROUND RAPIDLY FOR SEVERAL MINUTES, THEN SENDS A REPLY. BACK INSIDE THE CONDO IN THE SNOW-BOUND CITY, EUGENE’S PHONE SIGNALS AN INCOMING MESSAGE WITH THE SOUND OF LYNDON SLEWIDGE SINGING THE FINAL NOTES OF O CANADA.

EUGENE

Hey, the broker got back to me, Sharilyne. Looks like there are two yachts available for Christmas week. I’m sending you the details now.

EACH THUMB THROUGH THEIR PHONES FOR SEVERAL MINUTES. THE MOOD IN THE ROOM HAS NOTICEABLY LIGHTENED. EVEN THE LIGHTS ON THE CHRISTMAS TREE SEEM TO GLOW WARMER.

SHARILYNE

Did you look at the one called Reverie? It sounds pretty amazing.

(She reads from a website.)

“The luxury of her opulent interior and her unique on-board lifestyle offerings accommodate the needs of the most discerning guest.” That’s us!

EUGENE

It’s a 60-metre luxury motor yacht. That sounds perfect! It says here that “the experienced and highly professional crew will meet your every need and desire to ensure a magnificent voyage.” Should we go for it?

SHARILYNE

Absolutely. You call your mom and tell her the plan and I’ll invite some other friends and family, then start packing.

BRIEF MONTAGE:

EUGENE AND SHARILYNE CALL THEIR FRIENDS AND FAMILY, THEN PACK FOR A TROPICAL DESTINATION. FINALLY, THEY BOARD A FLIGHT, SINK INTO THEIR LEATHER-UPHOLSTERED SEATS WITH A SIGH OF RELIEF, AND A FLIGHT ATTENDANT MATERIALIZES TO HAND EACH A DRINK IN A HOLLOWED-OUT COCONUT TOPPED BY A TROPICAL BLOOM AND A LITTLE PAPER UMBRELLA. A MUSICAL MEDLEY THAT SOUNDS LIKE THE BEACH BOYS BUT IS NOT FOR REASONS OF COPYRIGHT INFRINGEMENT AND PRODUCTION COSTS PLAYS OVER THE FOOTAGE.

EXTERIOR EXPANSIVE YACHT DECK – DAYTIME

SHARILYNE AND EUGENE BOARD THE YACHT, THE TEAL WATERS AND PALM TREE SPIKES OF NASSAU VISIBLE BEYOND THE DECK’S GLEAMING GLASS RAILINGS. THE CREW LINES UP TO GREET THEM, AND CAPTAIN BRUCE EDMONDSON STEPS FORWARD TO INTRODUCE HIMSELF BRUSQUELY.

CAPTAIN EDMONDSON

Welcome to Reverie. I’m Captain Edmondson and I’ll be handling the boat for the next week or so. We should be leaving the harbour shortly. We can meet tomorrow once you get your sea legs to discuss our route.

EUGENE AND SHARILYNE OPEN THEIR MOUTHS TO REPLY, BUT THE CAPTAIN STRIDES AWAY ABRUPTLY.

SHARILYNE

(sotto voce)

Eugene, was it just me or did you find the captain a bit rude?

EUGENE

Yeah, he was not friendly. And it looks like he’s never been on this boat before.

SHARILYNE

Also, wasn’t he a bit…odorous?

EUGENE

I noticed that, yeah. Disgusting. Let’s see how things go tomorrow, maybe he’s just stressed about getting the trip underway.

Hey, let’s go over to the sun deck with a drink to watch the yacht leave the harbour. We should be on our way soon.

SHARILYNE

(brightening)

At least this boat presents the right balance of large yacht ambiance blended with the compelling attraction of a warm and congenial nautical experience.

THEY GO UP TO THE SUN DECK, STRETCH OUT ON LOUNGE CHAIRS AND STAFF MEMBERS BRING DRINKS AND SNACKS. THROUGH TIME-LAPSED FOOTAGE, WE SEE THEM FINISH THEIR DRINKS AND ORDER OTHERS. THEY WALK OVER TO THE RAILING TO PEER DOWN AT THE DOCK, WHERE WORKERS ARE STILL HAULING SUPPLIES ON BOARD. THEY RETURN TO THEIR LOUNGE CHAIRS, PAW LISTLESSLY AT THEIR PHONES, THEN APPEAR TO FALL ASLEEP. WHEN THEY AWAKEN, THEY GLANCE AROUND, CONFUSED, THEN SIGH IN DISAPPOINTMENT WHEN IT BECOMES APPARENT THAT THE YACHT IS STILL DOCKED. FINALLY, AS THE SKY IS DARKENING, THE YACHT LURCHES INTO MOTION.

SHARILYNE

It’s about time! I can’t wait to feel those open sea breezes.

EUGENE AND SHARILYNE TURN TO EACH OTHER AND CLINK GLASSES, BUT THEIR GRINS ARE WOBBLY RATHER THAN TRIUMPHANT.

EUGENE

(glancing around the deck)

Hey, don’t you think they’ll do some sort of safety talk so we know where the lifeboats and life jackets are? They did the last time we had a charter.

SHARILYNE

Oh, you’re right. Maybe they just wanted to give us time to settle in first.

(she frowns in concern, then appears to shake it off)

They’ll be setting dinner for us soon. I’ll tell the crew we’ll be ready after we leave the harbour.

THEY STAND AT THE RAILING TOGETHER DRINKING IN THE VIEW OF THE RECEDING SHORELINE. THERE IS A BRIEF AURA OF CONTENTMENT AROUND THEM AT LAST. THEN THE YACHT SHUDDERS, SLOWS AND GRINDS TO A STANDSTILL. A DISTANT, GUTTURAL VOICE FROM BELOW DECK YELLS “DROP ANCHOR” BECAUSE IT’S FUN TO ASSUME THAT SUPERYACHTS FUNCTION LIKE LEGO PIRATE SHIPS.  

EUGENE

What the?!

SHARILYNE

(turning to a uniformed crew member nearby)

What’s going on? Is there a problem?

CREW MEMBER

Captain says we’re anchoring here for the night.

EUGENE

Why?! We just left after waiting all day! Look, the harbour is right there.

TO MAKE HIS POINT, HE SOMEHOW PROCURES A HOCKEY STICK OUT OF THIN AIR, DROPS A PUCK ON THE DECK AND FIRES A WRIST SHOT OVER THE RAILING, WHERE IT BOUNCES OFF A PALM TREE ON SHORE AND INTO THE WATER JUST OFF THE YACHT’S BOW.

CREW MEMBER

I’m sorry, sir, I don’t know. Captain just said we have to stop here for the night. Can I get each of you another drink? Perhaps with a little paper umbrella?

EUGENE

I’m going to bed. This is ridiculous.

HE AND SHARILYNE LEAVE THE VOLUMINOUS SUN DECK AND RETIRE TO THEIR MAGNIFICENT 1200-SQ FT MASTER SUITE. IT LOOKS LIKE AN ABOVE-AVERAGE AIRPORT HOTEL IMPREGNATED THE STARSHIP ENTERPRISE. DESPITE THE SOLIDLY-BUILT GERMAN ENGINEERING THAT MAKES THE REVERIE A VERY QUIET AND PRIVATE YACHT, EUGENE TOSSES AND TURNS, UNABLE TO SLEEP. FINALLY, HE SHUFFLES TO THE SPACIOUS SKY LOUNGE WITH ITS 103” CINEMA SCREEN, PULLS OUT A DISC WITH SCRAWLED HANDWRITING ON IT AND POPS IT INTO THE DVD PLAYER. HE SINKS INTO ONE OF THE DEEP UPHOLSTERED SOFAS AS A HIGHLIGHT REEL OF DANIEL ALFREDSSON GOALS BEGINS TO PLAY ON THE SCREEN. BEFORE LONG, EUGENE IS SOUNDLY ASLEEP WITH A SOFT HALF-SMILE ON HIS FACE.

CUT TO:

INTERIOR YACHT BRIDGE – MORNING

EUGENE AND SHARILYNE SIT WITH THE CAPTAIN AT A LARGE WOODEN TABLE. SPREAD OUT IN FRONT OF THEM ARE A NUMBER OF WRINKLED MAPS, A GLOBE AND ASSORTED BRASS MEASUREMENT INSTRUMENTS BECAUSE AGAIN, I HAVE NO IDEA WHAT A YACHT LOOKS LIKE, SO AM GOING WITH LEGO PIRATE SHIP.

SHARILYNE

So, we’ll sail by ourselves for the first few days and then pick up the rest of our family and friends on the 27th in Exuma.

CAPTAIN

I can’t pick them up there. Boat won’t fit.

EUGENE

Well, what about Nassau? They could fly in there.

CAPTAIN

Can’t pick them up there either.

EUGENE

Why not?

CAPTAIN

Look, let’s talk about our route. Show me where you’d like to sail.

EUGENE

We want to sail between Andros and Eleuthera, here, around the Exuma District. We’ve taken charters through there before and the sailing is nice and calm.

HE TRACES A LINE ON THE MAP BETWEEN TWO LARGER BAHAMIAN ISLANDS, AROUND AN ARCHIPELAGO SPRINKLING OF SMALLER ISLANDS.  

CAPTAIN

The boat’s too big to sail between Anderson and Elora there.

SHARILYNE

Andros and Eleuthera.

CAPTAIN

Sure, fine, Anders and Eleanor. But the boat won’t fit in there.

SHARILYNE

No, see, we’re familiar with that area. There are coral reefs and shallower waters, but we know a lot of vessels that have sailed through there.

CAPTAIN

(becoming agitated)

I’m not sure what you’re not getting here. The draught of the boat is too large. It will end up like a beached whale. We need to sail east of Eeyore island, out into the Atlantic so we don’t run aground.  

EUGENE

We’ve sailed through there before and it was fine. We could get a specially experienced pilot if you like, to help you navigate.

CAPTAIN

(more agitated and upset)

I am the captain of this boat and I am not navigating between those islands.

EUGENE

(also agitated, flipping through his email, locating what he’s looking for and stabbing a finger at his phone screen)

Listen, the charter agreement I signed and paid for says, “The Captain shall comply with all reasonable orders given to him by the Charterer regarding the management,  operation and movement of the Vessel.” That’s me, I’m the Charterer. This is the Vessel. You are the Captain. And we want to sail between these two islands.

THE TRIO SIT STARING TENSELY AT EACH OTHER FOR A FEW BEATS.

CAPTAIN

I can see we’re not going to agree here. I’m going to call the charter agent.

HE EXITS THE BRIDGE AND CAN BE SEEN THROUGH THE WINDOWS PACING THE DECK, SPEAKING RAPIDLY INTO HIS CELL PHONE AND GESTICULATING WITH FRUSTRATION FOR SEVERAL MINUTES. EVENTUALLY HE RETURNS WITH A PRINTED MAP.

CAPTAIN

Look, I talked to the agent and he agrees with me. This is a 60-foot boat and it cannot safely sail through those islands, I don’t care how nice you think it would be. Here’s the route we’re going to take: east around Eleuthera, see?  

SHARILYNE

That route takes us out into the open Atlantic, absolutely not.

EUGENE

You’re going to hire a pilot to help you navigate and we are sailing among those islands, where it’s nice and calm.

CAPTAIN

(laughing derisively)

You must be confused. We are going around the islands. It’ll be fine, you’ll see.

CUT TO:

EXTERIOR YACHT – NIGHT

THE VESSEL IS TOSSED AGGRESSIVELY BY THE WAVES ON THE OPEN OCEAN IN THE DARKNESS. INSIDE THE LIGHTED BRIDGE, WE CAN SEE THE CAPTAIN, VISIBLY FLUSTERED, STRUGGLING TO CONTROL THE YACHT. PROBABLY IN REALITY HE WAS STEERING WITH SOME SLEEK AND MODERN METAL CONTROLLERS, BUT LET’S GO WITH A BURNISHED WOODEN SHIP’S WHEEL FOR THE SAKE OF AESTHETICS AND SEAFARING DRAMA.

CUT TO:

INTERIOR CABIN – NIGHT

EUGENE AND SHARILYNE SHIFT MISERABLY AROUND A DARK, CRAMPED CABIN, LURCHING UNSTEADILY WITH EVERY ROLL OF THE WAVES. THEY TAKE TURNS ATTEMPTING TO LIE ON THE BED OR STAND WITH A STEADYING HAND ON ONE WALL, BUT THEY CAN’T STAY STILL. THEIR EYES ARE DARK AND HOLLOWED FROM LACK OF SLEEP. PERIODICALLY ONE OR THE OTHER RUNS TO THE WASHROOM WITH A HAND CLAPPED OVER THEIR MOUTHS.

SHARILYNE

The crew suggested we move to this cabin further below deck so we wouldn’t feel so sick, but it’s done nothing to help, Eugene!

EUGENE

(violent retching in response)

HE EMERGES FROM THE BATHROOM, HIS FACE ASHEN.

What time is it, Sharilyne?

SHARILYNE

4 a.m. What time were we supposed to arrive?

EUGENE

We should have been there hours ago, this harrowing ordeal is taking twice as long as if we had gone between the islands like I told him to.

THE YACHT PITCHES WITH SUDDEN INCREASED VIOLENCE AND SHARILYNE SCREAMS IN TERROR.

SHARILYNE

What if the boat capsizes? What if it starts to sink and we’re stuck on the lower decks, Eugene?! We don’t even know where the safety gear is. We’re trapped down here! Oh my god.

SHE BEGINS TO HYPERVENTILATE AND WEEP WITH FEAR. EUGENE ATTEMPTS TO COMFORT HER, THEN RUNS TO THE BATHROOM RETCHING AGAIN.

TIME-LAPSE FOOTAGE OF THEIR CABIN IS OVERLAID WITH A TRANSPARENT MAP SHOWING THE BOAT’S ROUTE AROUND ELEUTHERA ISLAND THROUGH THE ATLANTIC, AND FINALLY BACK INTO THE CALMER WATERS ON THE WEST SIDE OF THE ISLAND. THE BACKGROUND BRIGHTENS TO DAYLIGHT.

CUT TO:

EXTERIOR BOAT DECK — MORNING 

CAPTAIN

(with an air of forced nonchalance and joviality)

Good morning! Bit of a jostling night at sea, wasn’t it? Hope you got a good night’s sleep! Thought we would head to Norman Cay for the next couple of days until we pick up the rest of your party, sound good?

EUGENE

(incredulous)

Norman Cay?! Are you serious?! You told us the boat was too large for that area and that’s why we had to sail to the far side of Eleuthera last night! You needlessly and recklessly exposed the vessel to the open Atlantic Ocean without barrier or break of any waves.

SHARILYNE

That was a harrowing ordeal that needlessly and punitively subjected us to hours upon hours of waves pummeling the yacht! Now you’re telling us it’s fine to sail among those islands?!

CAPTAIN

Look, I told you, the boat was too big for the route you wanted to take. Now, do you want to sail around Norman Cay or not?

EUGENE

(looks at Sharilyne in incredulity)

Sure, fine. Sounds good.

CAPTAIN

Great. Oh, and Merry Christmas!

HE PULLS A SANTA CAP OUT OF HIS POCKET AND PERCHES IT JAUNTILY ON HIS HEAD AS HE HEADS FOR THE BRIDGE, WHISTLING “ALL I WANT FOR CHRISTMAS IS YOU,” COMPLETE WITH MARIAH CAREY’S VOCAL EMBELLISHMENTS, PURELY BECAUSE THAT AMUSES ME AND I AM WRITING THIS SCRIPT.

MONTAGE:

WE SEE EUGENE AND SHARILYNE’S CHRISTMAS ABOARD THE YACHT. THEY OPEN PRESENTS BENEATH A TOWERING POTTED PALM STRUNG WITH LIGHTS AND CRYSTAL ORNAMENTS. IN THE MANNER OF OTHER WEALTHY PEOPLE LIKE THE BRITISH ROYAL FAMILY, THEY GIVE EACH OTHER GAG GIFTS. SHARILYNE HANDS EUGENE A LARGE, FLAT BOX AND HE OPENS IT WITH PALPABLE ANTICIPATION, THEN UNFURLS A 2007 THROWBACK OTTAWA SENATORS JERSEY WITH “ROBERTS” INSCRIBED ON THE NAMEPLATE.

EUGENE

(frowning briefly, perplexed, then grinning broadly)

Ah, I love it! You’re right, that would have been a fantastic trade, Muckler should have listened to me.

HE PASSES SHARILYNE A RECTANGULAR BOX.

Watch out, it’s breakable!

SHARILYNE UNWRAPS THE BOX, THEN CAREFULLY EXTRACTS A SCULPTURE ABOUT 18” TALL. IT IS A MALE FIGURE DRESSED LIKE A SPARTAN, LURIDLY SHIRTLESS, WEARING A BRONZED HELMET PERCHED ON THE BACK OF HIS HEAD SO THAT HIS EYES ARE COVERED LIKE HE’S WEARING HORSE BLINDERS. THE FIGURE HOLDS A SHIELD IN HIS LEFT HAND, ON THE BACK OF WHICH CAN BE GLIMPSED TINY WRITING THAT READS “RISE UP!” THE FIGURE POSSESSES AN UNMISTAKABLE AIR OF VALIANT EFFORT SUBSUMED BY ABSURD DEFEAT.

SHARILYNE

Oh my god, the Naked Spartan! Amazing!  

THEY CLINK GLASSES AND SETTLE BACK INTO THEIR ARMCHAIRS TO WATCH THE NOW-CALM SEAS BEYOND THE LOUNGE WINDOWS. OUTSIDE ON THE DECK, TWO CREW MEMBERS SURREPTITIOUSLY MOVE A SNOW MACHINE INTO PLACE AND TURN IT ON, SO THAT IT SHOOTS FINE FLAKES of FAKE SNOW INTO THE AIR, WHICH DRIFTS GENTLY DOWN OUTSIDE THE LOUNGE WINDOWS, BECAUSE IF I HAD A LOT OF MONEY, THAT IS WHAT I WOULD PAY SOMEONE TO DO AT CHRISTMAS.

CUT TO:

EXTERIOR YACHT DECK – MORNING

THE YACHT IS DOCKED AT THE ELEUTHERA ISLAND MARINA FOR EUGENE AND SHARILYNE’S FAMILY AND FRIENDS TO JOIN THEM ON THE CRUISE. A SMALL GROUP OF PEOPLE ARE WELCOMED WARMLY ABOARD, ALL OF WHOM CLEARLY KNOW EACH OTHER WELL AND HAVE NOT BEEN TOGETHER FOR A LONG TIME. THERE IS A SPECIAL FOCUS ON VERA, EUGENE’S MOTHER, A SPIRITED MATRIARCHAL FIGURE IN SOMEWHAT FRAGILE HEALTH. THE SOUNDTRACK TO THIS REUNION SOUNDS LIKE THE TINKLY SENTIMENTAL MUSIC AT THE END OF JOHN WILLIAMS’S SCORE FOR “HOME ALONE,” BUT A JANKY STARBUCKS VERSION OF THAT, DIFFERENT ENOUGH TO AVOID LEGAL TROUBLE AND HEFTY RIGHTS PAYMENTS.

EUGENE

(turning to the captain once everyone is settled on board)

So, let’s head south, on the west side of the Exuma District, where the waters will be calm.

CAPTAIN

We can’t. We’ve been through this before. Big boat, shallow waters, won’t fit.

EUGENE

Last time you took us out into the open ocean a few days ago was a nightmare. I am telling you to stay west of these islands, in the sheltered water.

CAPTAIN

There’s no other option, we have to go around to the east. It’ll be rough getting there, but calm once we reach the next island, you’ll see.

HE TURNS ON HIS HEEL AND WALKS AWAY. EUGENE AND SHARILYNE LOOK AT EACH OTHER WITH DREAD, BUT THEN PLASTER NERVOUS SMILES ON THEIR FACES BEFORE THEIR GUESTS NOTICE.

MONTAGE:

MISERY AT SEA. THE YACHT IS AGAIN TOSSED VIOLENTLY BY THE ATLANTIC, WITH SOME OF EUGENE AND SHARILYNE’S FRIENDS AND FAMILY CRAWLING ON ALL FOURS TO GET ACROSS THE PITCHING DECKS. VERA SITS FEARFULLY IN A STURDY CHAIR, A CAREGIVER STEADYING HER TO KEEP HER FROM TUMBLING OUT OF HER SEAT. ALMOST ALL OF THE GUESTS SUFFER VIOLENT BOUTS OF VOMITING FROM THE SAILING CONDITIONS. AT ONE POINT, SEVERAL GUESTS ARE SITTING IN THE DINING ROOM SIPPING LISTLESSLY AT GLASSES OF GINGER ALE AND NIBBLING PLAIN BREAD WHEN THE BOAT SUDDENLY LURCHES TO ONE SIDE AND A DECK CHAIR CRASHES THROUGH THE GLASS PARTITION ABOVE THE DINING AREA. SHARDS OF BROKEN GLASS RAIN DOWN, NARROWLY MISSING THE GUESTS WHO SCREAM IN FRIGHT.

EVENTUALLY, THE SEAS CALM AS THE YACHT APPROACHES A LANDMASS WITH A SHELTERED HARBOUR.

CAPTAIN

See, I told you it would calm down when we got to Cat Island! Smooth as glass now. This is Hawks Nest Marina, an ideal location to disembark and have some beach time. We can have a beachside barbecue here tomorrow, sound good?

THE PASSENGERS DISEMBARK, STILL SLIGHTLY WOBBLY ON THEIR FEET, AND GATHER ON A DOCK. THEY WALK TOWARD THE BEACH, THEN SUDDENLY STOP SHORT. THE CAMERA IS BEHIND THEM AND PANS UPWARD TO SHOW US WHAT HAS GIVEN THEM PAUSE: THE BEACH IS FESTOONED WITH SIGNS READING “DO NOT SWIM IN THE WATER DUE TO SHARKS.” SHARILYNE PULLS OUT HER PHONE AND RAPIDLY TAPS ON ITS SCREEN. WE PEER OVER HER SHOULDER AS SHE CLICKS ON THE FIRST WEBSITE ABOUT HAWK’S NEST MARINA AND READS: “MOST AFTERNOONS HAWK’S NEST MARINA FUEL DOCK IS SURROUNDED BY SHARKS FEEDING OFF ALL THE CATCH OF THE DAY! IT’S LIKE BEING AT YOUR OWN AQUARIUM.” THE GROUP TURNS AROUND INSTANTLY AND REBOARDS THE YACHT.

CUT TO:

EXTERIOR YACHT DECK – DAYTIME 

IT IS NOW JANUARY 1, THE LAST DAY OF THE CRUISE.

EUGENE

I don’t understand. We’re at Exuma right now, why won’t you let us disembark here?

CAPTAIN

It’s too rough, it’s not safe for your mother to disembark here.

SHARILYNE

(looking over the railing at the water)

The waves are exactly the same as they were when Vera boarded the boat.  

EUGENE

We’re leaving together on the dinghys, the same way my mother arrived.

CAPTAIN

I’m not letting anyone off this ship, I told you it’s not safe here! Now, let me captain the ship. I’ll take us back to Nassau and you can disembark there.

SHARILYNE

We don’t need to do that. Why don’t you let some of us disembark here and you can drop the others off at any island with an airport and calm waters, if you think it’s unsafe for Vera or anyone else to disembark here. You could even drop them off where we picked them up.

CAPTAIN

No, I’m not landing here for you to disembark.

EUGENE

Look, I have to make it to an important medical appointment. I need to get off this boat today.

CAPTAIN

I’ll let you all disembark in Nassau where we started. We’re going around the eastern edge of Eleuthera Island to get there, for reasons we’ve already been over.

SHARILYNE

(instantly distraught)

We are not going back out onto the open ocean! I cannot experience that severe fear and illness again, and I won’t let you subject our family and friends to that experience.

EUGENE

Just stop the boat anywhere and let us get off, we don’t care where. We want off this boat now. You could let us off at Eleuthera where you picked up our guests a few days ago, or any of the other islands with airports.

CAPTAIN

No, those are all unsafe. I can’t let you off in any of those places. We’re going east of Eleuthera to get you back to Nassau.

MONTAGE:

MORE SEAFARING SUFFERING. THE BOAT IS TOSSED BY THE ROUGH SEAS AND THE PASSENGERS LURCH AROUND MISERABLY ON BOARD. THERE IS COPIOUS VOMITING.

GUEST 1

I am suffering from severe illness.

GUEST 2

I am suffering severe emotional harm.

GUEST 3

I feel like we are being confined against our will.

GUEST 1

How long have we been out here being buffeted needlessly by the rough seas?

GUEST 3

18 hours being punitively compelled to sail back to the starting point against our will!

GUEST 2

Oh, thank god. There’s Nassau!

CUT TO:

EXTERIOR YACHT DECK IN NASSAU MARINA – SUNSET

THE CAPTAIN STANDS ON THE DECK CASUALLY SALUTING EACH OF THE PASSENGERS AS THEY DISEMBARK, OFFERING HIM BALEFUL GLARES AS THEY GO.

THE MELNYK PARTY STANDS TOGETHER IN A BEDRAGGLED KNOT ON THE JETTY, GAZING UP AT THE YACHT FROM WHICH THEY HAVE FINALLY DISEMBARKED. THERE IS PROLONGED SILENCE AS THEY EACH ATTEMPT TO METABOLIZE THE JOURNEY THEY HAVE JUST COMPLETED.

EUGENE

Well, that was anything other than the relaxing luxury holiday experience we were promised.

SHARILYNE

It was a days-long voyage spent managing intense vomiting, vertigo, sleepless nights, severe anxiety and fear over potential capsizing or sinking.

VERA

Don’t forget dodging shards of glass as deck chairs not properly secured careened into glass railings and rained shards of glass on the dining area.

GUEST 1

That was a voyage marred with fear and uncertainty.

GUEST 2

No one seemed to be in charge or concern themselves with safety.

GUEST 3

Let alone a luxury experience!  

EUGENE

That captain was overwhelmed and out of control. All he did was scream at and deride the crew in front of us.

SHARILYNE

This was a harrowing and destructive voyage full of needless pain and injury.

EUGENE

Let’s go home, everyone. We’re all sick and exhausted, and I don’t know about you, but I am fearful of ever boarding another boat.

THE CAMERA PANS AWAY ABOVE THEM AS THEY BEGIN TO SHUFFLE DEJECTEDLY DOWN THE JETTY BACK TO DRY LAND. THEN THE CAMERA PULLS IN AGAIN ON THE YACHT, ZOOMING IN OVER ITS DECK AND ALL THE WAY INTO THE MAIN DECK LOUNGE.

A LARGE, LEATHER-BOUND, GILT-EDGED BOOK SITS ON A SHELF BESIDE A CHAIR. THE BEARDED ELDERLY MAN FROM THE OPENING SCENE TURNS AND PULLS THE BOOK FROM THE SHELF, TURNING IT TOWARD THE CAMERA SO THAT WE CAN SEE ITS COVER: “GUEST BOOK.” HE FLIPS CAREFULLY THROUGH THE PAGES UNTIL HE FINDS WHAT HE’S LOOKING FOR, THEN POINTS AT ONE PAGE WITH A MERRY TWINKLE IN HIS EYE.

HANDWRITTEN GUEST BOOK ENTRY

Dear Reverie Crew

Thank you so much for such an amazing trip! It was an experience I’m sure we will never forget. The few days we spent upon Reverie were action-packed, yet relaxing at the same time. The sea-bobs were a definite hit! The food was incredible as well.

New Years was a great time; the decorations were absolutely gorgeous! The top deck was definitely memorable as well. Thank you so much for making this such a great experience! This was an amazing way to start the new year.

The Melnyk Group

THE BEARDED MAN CHUCKLES SOFTLY TO HIMSELF, THEN CLOSES THE BOOK AND RETURNS IT TO THE SHELF BESIDE HIM. LAYING HIS FINGER ASIDE OF HIS NOSE AND GIVING A NOD, HE DISAPPEARS IN A POUF OF RED AND GREEN GLITTER.

A FAINTLY ECHOING “HO HO HO” CAN BE HEARD AS THE SCREEN FADES TO BLACK.

-THE END-

The post The nightmare cruise before Christmas appeared first on Macleans.ca.


.single-article-container {
font-family: ‘Courier Prime’, monospace;
}
.single-article-text p {
margin-top: 0;
margin-bottom: 0;
}
.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-7>li:before {
content: “025cb ”
}

.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-6>li:before {
content: “025cf ”
}

.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-5>li:before {
content: “025a0 ”
}

.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-8>li:before {
content: “025a0 ”
}

ul.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-3 {
list-style-type: none
}

ul.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-2 {
list-style-type: none
}

.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-0>li:before {
content: ” ”
}

ul.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-1 {
list-style-type: none
}

ul.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-0 {
list-style-type: none
}

.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-1>li:before {
content: “025cb ”
}

ul.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-7 {
list-style-type: none
}

ul.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-6 {
list-style-type: none
}

ul.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-5 {
list-style-type: none
}

ul.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-4 {
list-style-type: none
}

.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-3>li:before {
content: “025cf ”
}

.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-2>li:before {
content: “025a0 ”
}

.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-4>li:before {
content: “025cb ”
}

ul.lst-kix_5oq7aydow7f4-8 {
list-style-type: none
}

ol {
margin: 0;
padding: 0
}

table td,
table th {
padding: 0
}

.c9 {
margin-left: 36pt;
padding-top: 12pt;
padding-bottom: 12pt;
line-height: 1.0;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: left;
height: 11pt
}

.c3 {
color: #000000;
font-weight: 400;
text-decoration: none;
vertical-align: baseline;
font-size: 12pt;
font-family: ‘Courier Prime’, monospace;
font-style: normal
}

.c4 {
padding-top: 0pt;
padding-bottom: 10pt;
line-height: 1.0;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: center;
height: 11pt
}

.c1 {
color: #000000;
font-weight: 700;
text-decoration: none;
vertical-align: baseline;
font-size: 12pt;
font-family: ‘Courier Prime’, monospace;
font-style: normal
}

.c13 {
color: #000000;
font-weight: 400;
text-decoration: none;
vertical-align: baseline;
font-size: 11pt;
font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif;
font-style: normal
}

.c6 {
margin-left: 36pt !important;
padding-top: 10pt;
padding-bottom: 12pt;
line-height: 1.0;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: left
}

.c10 {
margin-left: 36pt;
padding-top: 12pt;
padding-bottom: 12pt;
line-height: 1.0;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: center
}

.c0 {
margin-left: 12.3pt;
padding-top: 13.6pt;
padding-bottom: 0pt;
line-height: 1.9158997535705566;
text-align: justify;
margin-right: 13.6pt;
height: 11pt
}

.c27 {
color: #000000;
font-weight: 400;
text-decoration: none;
vertical-align: baseline;
font-size: 11pt;
font-family: ‘Courier Prime’, monospace;
font-style: normal
}

.c16 {
padding-top: 12pt;
padding-bottom: 12pt;
line-height: 1.0;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: center
}

.c19 {
-webkit-text-decoration-skip: none;
color: #000000;
text-decoration: underline;
vertical-align: baseline;
text-decoration-skip-ink: none;
font-style: normal
}

.c18 {
padding-top: 0pt;
padding-bottom: 10pt;
line-height: 1.0;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: center
}

.c2 {
padding-top: 10pt;
padding-bottom: 12pt;
line-height: 1.0;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: right
}

.c5 {
padding-top: 10pt;
padding-bottom: 12pt;
line-height: 1.0;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: center
}

.c20 {
padding-top: 12pt;
padding-bottom: 12pt;
line-height: 1.0;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: left
}

.c28 {
padding-top: 0pt;
padding-bottom: 0pt;
line-height: 1.15;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: left
}

.c29 {
padding-top: 0pt;
padding-bottom: 10pt;
line-height: 1.0;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: left
}

.c25 {
padding-top: 12pt;
padding-bottom: 12pt;
line-height: 1.0;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: right
}

.c8 {
padding-top: 10pt;
padding-bottom: 12pt;
line-height: 1.0;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: left
}

.c30 {
padding-top: 0pt;
padding-bottom: 10pt;
line-height: 1.0;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: right
}

.c21 {
color: #000000;
text-decoration: none;
vertical-align: baseline;
font-style: italic
}

.c11 {
font-size: 12pt;
font-family: ‘Courier Prime’, monospace;
font-weight: 700
}

.c15 {
font-size: 12pt;
font-family: ‘Courier Prime’, monospace;
font-weight: 400
}

.c23 {
max-width: 432pt;
padding: 72pt 72pt 72pt 108pt
}

.c24 {
font-style: italic
}

.c7 {
background-color: #ffffff
}

.c12 {
height: 11pt
}

.c14 {
margin-left: 36pt !important
}

.title {
padding-top: 0pt;
color: #000000;
font-size: 26pt;
padding-bottom: 3pt;
font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif;
line-height: 1.15;
page-break-after: avoid;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: left
}

.subtitle {
padding-top: 0pt;
color: #666666;
font-size: 15pt;
padding-bottom: 16pt;
font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif;
line-height: 1.15;
page-break-after: avoid;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: left
}

li {
color: #000000;
font-size: 11pt;
font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif
}

p {
margin: 0;
color: #000000;
font-size: 11pt;
font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif
}

h1 {
padding-top: 20pt;
color: #000000;
font-size: 20pt;
padding-bottom: 6pt;
font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif;
line-height: 1.15;
page-break-after: avoid;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: left
}

h2 {
padding-top: 18pt;
color: #000000;
font-size: 16pt;
padding-bottom: 6pt;
font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif;
line-height: 1.15;
page-break-after: avoid;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: left
}

h3 {
padding-top: 16pt;
color: #434343;
font-size: 14pt;
padding-bottom: 4pt;
font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif;
line-height: 1.15;
page-break-after: avoid;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: left
}

h4 {
padding-top: 14pt;
color: #666666;
font-size: 12pt;
padding-bottom: 4pt;
font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif;
line-height: 1.15;
page-break-after: avoid;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: left
}

h5 {
padding-top: 12pt;
color: #666666;
font-size: 11pt;
padding-bottom: 4pt;
font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif;
line-height: 1.15;
page-break-after: avoid;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: left
}

h6 {
padding-top: 12pt;
color: #666666;
font-size: 11pt;
padding-bottom: 4pt;
font-family: Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif;
line-height: 1.15;
page-break-after: avoid;
font-style: italic;
orphans: 2;
widows: 2;
text-align: left
}

CHRISTMAS CRUISE GONE WRONG

Written by:

Shannon Proudfoot

In collaboration with:

Documents filed in the

Southern District of Florida

U.S. Federal Court

* This fictionalized account is based on a lawsuit filed by Sharilyne Anderson and Vera Melnyk. None of the claims have been tested in court.

INTERIOR COZY COTTAGE-LIKE ROOM – NIGHT

FOUR DOE-EYED CHILDREN WEARING PAJAMAS ARE GATHERED AT THE FEET OF A BEARDED ELDERLY MAN CLAD IN RED VELOUR PANTS, A WHITE THERMAL LONG-SLEEVED SHIRT AND SUSPENDERS. A FIREPLACE CRACKLES FESTIVELY IN THE BACKGROUND. THE MAN TURNS TO A BOOKSHELF BESIDE HIS CHAIR AND RETRIEVES A LARGE, LEATHER-BOUND VOLUME WITH GILT-EDGED PAGES. WITH GREAT CARE, HE OPENS ITS COVER AND TURNS BACK TO HIS RAPT AUDIENCE, BECKONING THEM CLOSER.

MAN

Children, tonight I have for you a story about a very special Christmas voyage that did not go at all as planned. This little adventure was supposed to take place in waters as warm and gentle as a hug from Mrs. Claus (he chuckles), but instead it unfolded on the unforgiving blizzard of the high seas. It all began one year ago, in a place that is at once very distant and ever so near to us now: PandemicLand.

SCENE DISSOLVES TO:

INTERIOR LUXURIOUS CONDO – NIGHT

THROUGH THE WINDOWS, A LARGE CITY DUSTED WITH SNOW IS VISIBLE. IN ONE CORNER OF THE ROOM STANDS A TOWERING CHRISTMAS TREE BEDECKED IN RED, GOLD AND BLACK DECORATIONS; AT THE APEX OF THE TREE IS AN ENORMOUS GOLD CENTURION HELMET. A MAN AND WOMAN, EUGENE AND SHARILYNE, RECLINE ON ADJACENT SOFAS. HE IDLY FLIPS TV CHANNELS WHILE SHE THUMBS THROUGH HER PHONE. THERE IS A PALPABLE AIR OF RESTLESSNESS AND ENNUI.

SHARILYNE

I’m sick of being cooped up like this, Eugene. Who knows when this pandemic will end? Can’t we find some way to escape our Canadian isolated existence over the holidays?

EUGENE

(suddenly brightening)

You know, that’s a great idea. We should go somewhere warm, and take our family and friends with us. Hey, what about a Christmas cruise on that yacht charter in the Bahamas that we previously enjoyed?

SHARILYNE

Oh, I love that idea.

EUGENE

I’ll get in touch with the charter broker we dealt with last time.

BRIEF MONTAGE:

EUGENE TAPS RAPIDLY ON HIS PHONE. AT THE RECEIVING END OF THAT MESSAGE, A PHONE PINGS NEXT TO A MAN SITTING IN A TROPICAL ENVIRONMENT, WITH PALM TREES AND OPEN WATER VISIBLE BEHIND HIM. HE READS THE MESSAGE, CLICKS AROUND RAPIDLY FOR SEVERAL MINUTES, THEN SENDS A REPLY. BACK INSIDE THE CONDO IN THE SNOW-BOUND CITY, EUGENE’S PHONE SIGNALS AN INCOMING MESSAGE WITH THE SOUND OF LYNDON SLEWIDGE SINGING THE FINAL NOTES OF O CANADA.

EUGENE

Hey, the broker got back to me, Sharilyne. Looks like there are two yachts available for Christmas week. I’m sending you the details now.

EACH THUMB THROUGH THEIR PHONES FOR SEVERAL MINUTES. THE MOOD IN THE ROOM HAS NOTICEABLY LIGHTENED. EVEN THE LIGHTS ON THE CHRISTMAS TREE SEEM TO GLOW WARMER.

SHARILYNE

Did you look at the one called Reverie? It sounds pretty amazing.

(She reads from a website.)

“The luxury of her opulent interior and her unique on-board lifestyle offerings accommodate the needs of the most discerning guest.” That’s us!

EUGENE

It’s a 60-metre luxury motor yacht. That sounds perfect! It says here that “the experienced and highly professional crew will meet your every need and desire to ensure a magnificent voyage.” Should we go for it?

SHARILYNE

Absolutely. You call your mom and tell her the plan and I’ll invite some other friends and family, then start packing.

BRIEF MONTAGE:

EUGENE AND SHARILYNE CALL THEIR FRIENDS AND FAMILY, THEN PACK FOR A TROPICAL DESTINATION. FINALLY, THEY BOARD A FLIGHT, SINK INTO THEIR LEATHER-UPHOLSTERED SEATS WITH A SIGH OF RELIEF, AND A FLIGHT ATTENDANT MATERIALIZES TO HAND EACH A DRINK IN A HOLLOWED-OUT COCONUT TOPPED BY A TROPICAL BLOOM AND A LITTLE PAPER UMBRELLA. A MUSICAL MEDLEY THAT SOUNDS LIKE THE BEACH BOYS BUT IS NOT FOR REASONS OF COPYRIGHT INFRINGEMENT AND PRODUCTION COSTS PLAYS OVER THE FOOTAGE.

EXTERIOR EXPANSIVE YACHT DECK – DAYTIME

SHARILYNE AND EUGENE BOARD THE YACHT, THE TEAL WATERS AND PALM TREE SPIKES OF NASSAU VISIBLE BEYOND THE DECK’S GLEAMING GLASS RAILINGS. THE CREW LINES UP TO GREET THEM, AND CAPTAIN BRUCE EDMONDSON STEPS FORWARD TO INTRODUCE HIMSELF BRUSQUELY.

CAPTAIN EDMONDSON

Welcome to Reverie. I’m Captain Edmondson and I’ll be handling the boat for the next week or so. We should be leaving the harbour shortly. We can meet tomorrow once you get your sea legs to discuss our route.

EUGENE AND SHARILYNE OPEN THEIR MOUTHS TO REPLY, BUT THE CAPTAIN STRIDES AWAY ABRUPTLY.

SHARILYNE

(sotto voce)

Eugene, was it just me or did you find the captain a bit rude?

EUGENE

Yeah, he was not friendly. And it looks like he’s never been on this boat before.

SHARILYNE

Also, wasn’t he a bit…odorous?

EUGENE

I noticed that, yeah. Disgusting. Let’s see how things go tomorrow, maybe he’s just stressed about getting the trip underway.

Hey, let’s go over to the sun deck with a drink to watch the yacht leave the harbour. We should be on our way soon.

SHARILYNE

(brightening)

At least this boat presents the right balance of large yacht ambiance blended with the compelling attraction of a warm and congenial nautical experience.

THEY GO UP TO THE SUN DECK, STRETCH OUT ON LOUNGE CHAIRS AND STAFF MEMBERS BRING DRINKS AND SNACKS. THROUGH TIME-LAPSED FOOTAGE, WE SEE THEM FINISH THEIR DRINKS AND ORDER OTHERS. THEY WALK OVER TO THE RAILING TO PEER DOWN AT THE DOCK, WHERE WORKERS ARE STILL HAULING SUPPLIES ON BOARD. THEY RETURN TO THEIR LOUNGE CHAIRS, PAW LISTLESSLY AT THEIR PHONES, THEN APPEAR TO FALL ASLEEP. WHEN THEY AWAKEN, THEY GLANCE AROUND, CONFUSED, THEN SIGH IN DISAPPOINTMENT WHEN IT BECOMES APPARENT THAT THE YACHT IS STILL DOCKED. FINALLY, AS THE SKY IS DARKENING, THE YACHT LURCHES INTO MOTION.

SHARILYNE

It’s about time! I can’t wait to feel those open sea breezes.

EUGENE AND SHARILYNE TURN TO EACH OTHER AND CLINK GLASSES, BUT THEIR GRINS ARE WOBBLY RATHER THAN TRIUMPHANT.

EUGENE

(glancing around the deck)

Hey, don’t you think they’ll do some sort of safety talk so we know where the lifeboats and life jackets are? They did the last time we had a charter.

SHARILYNE

Oh, you’re right. Maybe they just wanted to give us time to settle in first.

(she frowns in concern, then appears to shake it off)

They’ll be setting dinner for us soon. I’ll tell the crew we’ll be ready after we leave the harbour.

THEY STAND AT THE RAILING TOGETHER DRINKING IN THE VIEW OF THE RECEDING SHORELINE. THERE IS A BRIEF AURA OF CONTENTMENT AROUND THEM AT LAST. THEN THE YACHT SHUDDERS, SLOWS AND GRINDS TO A STANDSTILL. A DISTANT, GUTTURAL VOICE FROM BELOW DECK YELLS “DROP ANCHOR” BECAUSE IT’S FUN TO ASSUME THAT SUPERYACHTS FUNCTION LIKE LEGO PIRATE SHIPS.  

EUGENE

What the?!

SHARILYNE

(turning to a uniformed crew member nearby)

What’s going on? Is there a problem?

CREW MEMBER

Captain says we’re anchoring here for the night.

EUGENE

Why?! We just left after waiting all day! Look, the harbour is right there.

TO MAKE HIS POINT, HE SOMEHOW PROCURES A HOCKEY STICK OUT OF THIN AIR, DROPS A PUCK ON THE DECK AND FIRES A WRIST SHOT OVER THE RAILING, WHERE IT BOUNCES OFF A PALM TREE ON SHORE AND INTO THE WATER JUST OFF THE YACHT’S BOW.

CREW MEMBER

I’m sorry, sir, I don’t know. Captain just said we have to stop here for the night. Can I get each of you another drink? Perhaps with a little paper umbrella?

EUGENE

I’m going to bed. This is ridiculous.

HE AND SHARILYNE LEAVE THE VOLUMINOUS SUN DECK AND RETIRE TO THEIR MAGNIFICENT 1200-SQ FT MASTER SUITE. IT LOOKS LIKE AN ABOVE-AVERAGE AIRPORT HOTEL IMPREGNATED THE STARSHIP ENTERPRISE. DESPITE THE SOLIDLY-BUILT GERMAN ENGINEERING THAT MAKES THE REVERIE A VERY QUIET AND PRIVATE YACHT, EUGENE TOSSES AND TURNS, UNABLE TO SLEEP. FINALLY, HE SHUFFLES TO THE SPACIOUS SKY LOUNGE WITH ITS 103” CINEMA SCREEN, PULLS OUT A DISC WITH SCRAWLED HANDWRITING ON IT AND POPS IT INTO THE DVD PLAYER. HE SINKS INTO ONE OF THE DEEP UPHOLSTERED SOFAS AS A HIGHLIGHT REEL OF DANIEL ALFREDSSON GOALS BEGINS TO PLAY ON THE SCREEN. BEFORE LONG, EUGENE IS SOUNDLY ASLEEP WITH A SOFT HALF-SMILE ON HIS FACE.

CUT TO:

INTERIOR YACHT BRIDGE – MORNING

EUGENE AND SHARILYNE SIT WITH THE CAPTAIN AT A LARGE WOODEN TABLE. SPREAD OUT IN FRONT OF THEM ARE A NUMBER OF WRINKLED MAPS, A GLOBE AND ASSORTED BRASS MEASUREMENT INSTRUMENTS BECAUSE AGAIN, I HAVE NO IDEA WHAT A YACHT LOOKS LIKE, SO AM GOING WITH LEGO PIRATE SHIP.

SHARILYNE

So, we’ll sail by ourselves for the first few days and then pick up the rest of our family and friends on the 27th in Exuma.

CAPTAIN

I can’t pick them up there. Boat won’t fit.

EUGENE

Well, what about Nassau? They could fly in there.

CAPTAIN

Can’t pick them up there either.

EUGENE

Why not?

CAPTAIN

Look, let’s talk about our route. Show me where you’d like to sail.

EUGENE

We want to sail between Andros and Eleuthera, here, around the Exuma District. We’ve taken charters through there before and the sailing is nice and calm.

HE TRACES A LINE ON THE MAP BETWEEN TWO LARGER BAHAMIAN ISLANDS, AROUND AN ARCHIPELAGO SPRINKLING OF SMALLER ISLANDS.  

CAPTAIN

The boat’s too big to sail between Anderson and Elora there.

SHARILYNE

Andros and Eleuthera.

CAPTAIN

Sure, fine, Anders and Eleanor. But the boat won’t fit in there.

SHARILYNE

No, see, we’re familiar with that area. There are coral reefs and shallower waters, but we know a lot of vessels that have sailed through there.

CAPTAIN

(becoming agitated)

I’m not sure what you’re not getting here. The draught of the boat is too large. It will end up like a beached whale. We need to sail east of Eeyore island, out into the Atlantic so we don’t run aground.  

EUGENE

We’ve sailed through there before and it was fine. We could get a specially experienced pilot if you like, to help you navigate.

CAPTAIN

(more agitated and upset)

I am the captain of this boat and I am not navigating between those islands.

EUGENE

(also agitated, flipping through his email, locating what he’s looking for and stabbing a finger at his phone screen)

Listen, the charter agreement I signed and paid for says, “The Captain shall comply with all reasonable orders given to him by the Charterer regarding the management,  operation and movement of the Vessel.” That’s me, I’m the Charterer. This is the Vessel. You are the Captain. And we want to sail between these two islands.

THE TRIO SIT STARING TENSELY AT EACH OTHER FOR A FEW BEATS.

CAPTAIN

I can see we’re not going to agree here. I’m going to call the charter agent.

HE EXITS THE BRIDGE AND CAN BE SEEN THROUGH THE WINDOWS PACING THE DECK, SPEAKING RAPIDLY INTO HIS CELL PHONE AND GESTICULATING WITH FRUSTRATION FOR SEVERAL MINUTES. EVENTUALLY HE RETURNS WITH A PRINTED MAP.

CAPTAIN

Look, I talked to the agent and he agrees with me. This is a 60-foot boat and it cannot safely sail through those islands, I don’t care how nice you think it would be. Here’s the route we’re going to take: east around Eleuthera, see?  

SHARILYNE

That route takes us out into the open Atlantic, absolutely not.

EUGENE

You’re going to hire a pilot to help you navigate and we are sailing among those islands, where it’s nice and calm.

CAPTAIN

(laughing derisively)

You must be confused. We are going around the islands. It’ll be fine, you’ll see.

CUT TO:

EXTERIOR YACHT – NIGHT

THE VESSEL IS TOSSED AGGRESSIVELY BY THE WAVES ON THE OPEN OCEAN IN THE DARKNESS. INSIDE THE LIGHTED BRIDGE, WE CAN SEE THE CAPTAIN, VISIBLY FLUSTERED, STRUGGLING TO CONTROL THE YACHT. PROBABLY IN REALITY HE WAS STEERING WITH SOME SLEEK AND MODERN METAL CONTROLLERS, BUT LET’S GO WITH A BURNISHED WOODEN SHIP’S WHEEL FOR THE SAKE OF AESTHETICS AND SEAFARING DRAMA.

CUT TO:

INTERIOR CABIN – NIGHT

EUGENE AND SHARILYNE SHIFT MISERABLY AROUND A DARK, CRAMPED CABIN, LURCHING UNSTEADILY WITH EVERY ROLL OF THE WAVES. THEY TAKE TURNS ATTEMPTING TO LIE ON THE BED OR STAND WITH A STEADYING HAND ON ONE WALL, BUT THEY CAN’T STAY STILL. THEIR EYES ARE DARK AND HOLLOWED FROM LACK OF SLEEP. PERIODICALLY ONE OR THE OTHER RUNS TO THE WASHROOM WITH A HAND CLAPPED OVER THEIR MOUTHS.

SHARILYNE

The crew suggested we move to this cabin further below deck so we wouldn’t feel so sick, but it’s done nothing to help, Eugene!

EUGENE

(violent retching in response)

HE EMERGES FROM THE BATHROOM, HIS FACE ASHEN.

What time is it, Sharilyne?

SHARILYNE

4 a.m. What time were we supposed to arrive?

EUGENE

We should have been there hours ago, this harrowing ordeal is taking twice as long as if we had gone between the islands like I told him to.

THE YACHT PITCHES WITH SUDDEN INCREASED VIOLENCE AND SHARILYNE SCREAMS IN TERROR.

SHARILYNE

What if the boat capsizes? What if it starts to sink and we’re stuck on the lower decks, Eugene?! We don’t even know where the safety gear is. We’re trapped down here! Oh my god.

SHE BEGINS TO HYPERVENTILATE AND WEEP WITH FEAR. EUGENE ATTEMPTS TO COMFORT HER, THEN RUNS TO THE BATHROOM RETCHING AGAIN.

TIME-LAPSE FOOTAGE OF THEIR CABIN IS OVERLAID WITH A TRANSPARENT MAP SHOWING THE BOAT’S ROUTE AROUND ELEUTHERA ISLAND THROUGH THE ATLANTIC, AND FINALLY BACK INTO THE CALMER WATERS ON THE WEST SIDE OF THE ISLAND. THE BACKGROUND BRIGHTENS TO DAYLIGHT.

CUT TO:

EXTERIOR BOAT DECK — MORNING 

CAPTAIN

(with an air of forced nonchalance and joviality)

Good morning! Bit of a jostling night at sea, wasn’t it? Hope you got a good night’s sleep! Thought we would head to Norman Cay for the next couple of days until we pick up the rest of your party, sound good?

EUGENE

(incredulous)

Norman Cay?! Are you serious?! You told us the boat was too large for that area and that’s why we had to sail to the far side of Eleuthera last night! You needlessly and recklessly exposed the vessel to the open Atlantic Ocean without barrier or break of any waves.

SHARILYNE

That was a harrowing ordeal that needlessly and punitively subjected us to hours upon hours of waves pummeling the yacht! Now you’re telling us it’s fine to sail among those islands?!

CAPTAIN

Look, I told you, the boat was too big for the route you wanted to take. Now, do you want to sail around Norman Cay or not?

EUGENE

(looks at Sharilyne in incredulity)

Sure, fine. Sounds good.

CAPTAIN

Great. Oh, and Merry Christmas!

HE PULLS A SANTA CAP OUT OF HIS POCKET AND PERCHES IT JAUNTILY ON HIS HEAD AS HE HEADS FOR THE BRIDGE, WHISTLING “ALL I WANT FOR CHRISTMAS IS YOU,” COMPLETE WITH MARIAH CAREY’S VOCAL EMBELLISHMENTS, PURELY BECAUSE THAT AMUSES ME AND I AM WRITING THIS SCRIPT.

MONTAGE:

WE SEE EUGENE AND SHARILYNE’S CHRISTMAS ABOARD THE YACHT. THEY OPEN PRESENTS BENEATH A TOWERING POTTED PALM STRUNG WITH LIGHTS AND CRYSTAL ORNAMENTS. IN THE MANNER OF OTHER WEALTHY PEOPLE LIKE THE BRITISH ROYAL FAMILY, THEY GIVE EACH OTHER GAG GIFTS. SHARILYNE HANDS EUGENE A LARGE, FLAT BOX AND HE OPENS IT WITH PALPABLE ANTICIPATION, THEN UNFURLS A 2007 THROWBACK OTTAWA SENATORS JERSEY WITH “ROBERTS” INSCRIBED ON THE NAMEPLATE.

EUGENE

(frowning briefly, perplexed, then grinning broadly)

Ah, I love it! You’re right, that would have been a fantastic trade, Muckler should have listened to me.

HE PASSES SHARILYNE A RECTANGULAR BOX.

Watch out, it’s breakable!

SHARILYNE UNWRAPS THE BOX, THEN CAREFULLY EXTRACTS A SCULPTURE ABOUT 18” TALL. IT IS A MALE FIGURE DRESSED LIKE A SPARTAN, LURIDLY SHIRTLESS, WEARING A BRONZED HELMET PERCHED ON THE BACK OF HIS HEAD SO THAT HIS EYES ARE COVERED LIKE HE’S WEARING HORSE BLINDERS. THE FIGURE HOLDS A SHIELD IN HIS LEFT HAND, ON THE BACK OF WHICH CAN BE GLIMPSED TINY WRITING THAT READS “RISE UP!” THE FIGURE POSSESSES AN UNMISTAKABLE AIR OF VALIANT EFFORT SUBSUMED BY ABSURD DEFEAT.

SHARILYNE

Oh my god, the Naked Spartan! Amazing!  

THEY CLINK GLASSES AND SETTLE BACK INTO THEIR ARMCHAIRS TO WATCH THE NOW-CALM SEAS BEYOND THE LOUNGE WINDOWS. OUTSIDE ON THE DECK, TWO CREW MEMBERS SURREPTITIOUSLY MOVE A SNOW MACHINE INTO PLACE AND TURN IT ON, SO THAT IT SHOOTS FINE FLAKES of FAKE SNOW INTO THE AIR, WHICH DRIFTS GENTLY DOWN OUTSIDE THE LOUNGE WINDOWS, BECAUSE IF I HAD A LOT OF MONEY, THAT IS WHAT I WOULD PAY SOMEONE TO DO AT CHRISTMAS.

CUT TO:

EXTERIOR YACHT DECK – MORNING

THE YACHT IS DOCKED AT THE ELEUTHERA ISLAND MARINA FOR EUGENE AND SHARILYNE’S FAMILY AND FRIENDS TO JOIN THEM ON THE CRUISE. A SMALL GROUP OF PEOPLE ARE WELCOMED WARMLY ABOARD, ALL OF WHOM CLEARLY KNOW EACH OTHER WELL AND HAVE NOT BEEN TOGETHER FOR A LONG TIME. THERE IS A SPECIAL FOCUS ON VERA, EUGENE’S MOTHER, A SPIRITED MATRIARCHAL FIGURE IN SOMEWHAT FRAGILE HEALTH. THE SOUNDTRACK TO THIS REUNION SOUNDS LIKE THE TINKLY SENTIMENTAL MUSIC AT THE END OF JOHN WILLIAMS’S SCORE FOR “HOME ALONE,” BUT A JANKY STARBUCKS VERSION OF THAT, DIFFERENT ENOUGH TO AVOID LEGAL TROUBLE AND HEFTY RIGHTS PAYMENTS.

EUGENE

(turning to the captain once everyone is settled on board)

So, let’s head south, on the west side of the Exuma District, where the waters will be calm.

CAPTAIN

We can’t. We’ve been through this before. Big boat, shallow waters, won’t fit.

EUGENE

Last time you took us out into the open ocean a few days ago was a nightmare. I am telling you to stay west of these islands, in the sheltered water.

CAPTAIN

There’s no other option, we have to go around to the east. It’ll be rough getting there, but calm once we reach the next island, you’ll see.

HE TURNS ON HIS HEEL AND WALKS AWAY. EUGENE AND SHARILYNE LOOK AT EACH OTHER WITH DREAD, BUT THEN PLASTER NERVOUS SMILES ON THEIR FACES BEFORE THEIR GUESTS NOTICE.

MONTAGE:

MISERY AT SEA. THE YACHT IS AGAIN TOSSED VIOLENTLY BY THE ATLANTIC, WITH SOME OF EUGENE AND SHARILYNE’S FRIENDS AND FAMILY CRAWLING ON ALL FOURS TO GET ACROSS THE PITCHING DECKS. VERA SITS FEARFULLY IN A STURDY CHAIR, A CAREGIVER STEADYING HER TO KEEP HER FROM TUMBLING OUT OF HER SEAT. ALMOST ALL OF THE GUESTS SUFFER VIOLENT BOUTS OF VOMITING FROM THE SAILING CONDITIONS. AT ONE POINT, SEVERAL GUESTS ARE SITTING IN THE DINING ROOM SIPPING LISTLESSLY AT GLASSES OF GINGER ALE AND NIBBLING PLAIN BREAD WHEN THE BOAT SUDDENLY LURCHES TO ONE SIDE AND A DECK CHAIR CRASHES THROUGH THE GLASS PARTITION ABOVE THE DINING AREA. SHARDS OF BROKEN GLASS RAIN DOWN, NARROWLY MISSING THE GUESTS WHO SCREAM IN FRIGHT.

EVENTUALLY, THE SEAS CALM AS THE YACHT APPROACHES A LANDMASS WITH A SHELTERED HARBOUR.

CAPTAIN

See, I told you it would calm down when we got to Cat Island! Smooth as glass now. This is Hawks Nest Marina, an ideal location to disembark and have some beach time. We can have a beachside barbecue here tomorrow, sound good?

THE PASSENGERS DISEMBARK, STILL SLIGHTLY WOBBLY ON THEIR FEET, AND GATHER ON A DOCK. THEY WALK TOWARD THE BEACH, THEN SUDDENLY STOP SHORT. THE CAMERA IS BEHIND THEM AND PANS UPWARD TO SHOW US WHAT HAS GIVEN THEM PAUSE: THE BEACH IS FESTOONED WITH SIGNS READING “DO NOT SWIM IN THE WATER DUE TO SHARKS.” SHARILYNE PULLS OUT HER PHONE AND RAPIDLY TAPS ON ITS SCREEN. WE PEER OVER HER SHOULDER AS SHE CLICKS ON THE FIRST WEBSITE ABOUT HAWK’S NEST MARINA AND READS: “MOST AFTERNOONS HAWK’S NEST MARINA FUEL DOCK IS SURROUNDED BY SHARKS FEEDING OFF ALL THE CATCH OF THE DAY! IT’S LIKE BEING AT YOUR OWN AQUARIUM.” THE GROUP TURNS AROUND INSTANTLY AND REBOARDS THE YACHT.

CUT TO:

EXTERIOR YACHT DECK – DAYTIME 

IT IS NOW JANUARY 1, THE LAST DAY OF THE CRUISE.

EUGENE

I don’t understand. We’re at Exuma right now, why won’t you let us disembark here?

CAPTAIN

It’s too rough, it’s not safe for your mother to disembark here.

SHARILYNE

(looking over the railing at the water)

The waves are exactly the same as they were when Vera boarded the boat.  

EUGENE

We’re leaving together on the dinghys, the same way my mother arrived.

CAPTAIN

I’m not letting anyone off this ship, I told you it’s not safe here! Now, let me captain the ship. I’ll take us back to Nassau and you can disembark there.

SHARILYNE

We don’t need to do that. Why don’t you let some of us disembark here and you can drop the others off at any island with an airport and calm waters, if you think it’s unsafe for Vera or anyone else to disembark here. You could even drop them off where we picked them up.

CAPTAIN

No, I’m not landing here for you to disembark.

EUGENE

Look, I have to make it to an important medical appointment. I need to get off this boat today.

CAPTAIN

I’ll let you all disembark in Nassau where we started. We’re going around the eastern edge of Eleuthera Island to get there, for reasons we’ve already been over.

SHARILYNE

(instantly distraught)

We are not going back out onto the open ocean! I cannot experience that severe fear and illness again, and I won’t let you subject our family and friends to that experience.

EUGENE

Just stop the boat anywhere and let us get off, we don’t care where. We want off this boat now. You could let us off at Eleuthera where you picked up our guests a few days ago, or any of the other islands with airports.

CAPTAIN

No, those are all unsafe. I can’t let you off in any of those places. We’re going east of Eleuthera to get you back to Nassau.

MONTAGE:

MORE SEAFARING SUFFERING. THE BOAT IS TOSSED BY THE ROUGH SEAS AND THE PASSENGERS LURCH AROUND MISERABLY ON BOARD. THERE IS COPIOUS VOMITING.

GUEST 1

I am suffering from severe illness.

GUEST 2

I am suffering severe emotional harm.

GUEST 3

I feel like we are being confined against our will.

GUEST 1

How long have we been out here being buffeted needlessly by the rough seas?

GUEST 3

18 hours being punitively compelled to sail back to the starting point against our will!

GUEST 2

Oh, thank god. There’s Nassau!

CUT TO:

EXTERIOR YACHT DECK IN NASSAU MARINA – SUNSET

THE CAPTAIN STANDS ON THE DECK CASUALLY SALUTING EACH OF THE PASSENGERS AS THEY DISEMBARK, OFFERING HIM BALEFUL GLARES AS THEY GO.

THE MELNYK PARTY STANDS TOGETHER IN A BEDRAGGLED KNOT ON THE JETTY, GAZING UP AT THE YACHT FROM WHICH THEY HAVE FINALLY DISEMBARKED. THERE IS PROLONGED SILENCE AS THEY EACH ATTEMPT TO METABOLIZE THE JOURNEY THEY HAVE JUST COMPLETED.

EUGENE

Well, that was anything other than the relaxing luxury holiday experience we were promised.

SHARILYNE

It was a days-long voyage spent managing intense vomiting, vertigo, sleepless nights, severe anxiety and fear over potential capsizing or sinking.

VERA

Don’t forget dodging shards of glass as deck chairs not properly secured careened into glass railings and rained shards of glass on the dining area.

GUEST 1

That was a voyage marred with fear and uncertainty.

GUEST 2

No one seemed to be in charge or concern themselves with safety.

GUEST 3

Let alone a luxury experience!  

EUGENE

That captain was overwhelmed and out of control. All he did was scream at and deride the crew in front of us.

SHARILYNE

This was a harrowing and destructive voyage full of needless pain and injury.

EUGENE

Let’s go home, everyone. We’re all sick and exhausted, and I don’t know about you, but I am fearful of ever boarding another boat.

THE CAMERA PANS AWAY ABOVE THEM AS THEY BEGIN TO SHUFFLE DEJECTEDLY DOWN THE JETTY BACK TO DRY LAND. THEN THE CAMERA PULLS IN AGAIN ON THE YACHT, ZOOMING IN OVER ITS DECK AND ALL THE WAY INTO THE MAIN DECK LOUNGE.

A LARGE, LEATHER-BOUND, GILT-EDGED BOOK SITS ON A SHELF BESIDE A CHAIR. THE BEARDED ELDERLY MAN FROM THE OPENING SCENE TURNS AND PULLS THE BOOK FROM THE SHELF, TURNING IT TOWARD THE CAMERA SO THAT WE CAN SEE ITS COVER: “GUEST BOOK.” HE FLIPS CAREFULLY THROUGH THE PAGES UNTIL HE FINDS WHAT HE’S LOOKING FOR, THEN POINTS AT ONE PAGE WITH A MERRY TWINKLE IN HIS EYE.

HANDWRITTEN GUEST BOOK ENTRY

Dear Reverie Crew

Thank you so much for such an amazing trip! It was an experience I’m sure we will never forget. The few days we spent upon Reverie were action-packed, yet relaxing at the same time. The sea-bobs were a definite hit! The food was incredible as well.

New Years was a great time; the decorations were absolutely gorgeous! The top deck was definitely memorable as well. Thank you so much for making this such a great experience! This was an amazing way to start the new year.

The Melnyk Group

THE BEARDED MAN CHUCKLES SOFTLY TO HIMSELF, THEN CLOSES THE BOOK AND RETURNS IT TO THE SHELF BESIDE HIM. LAYING HIS FINGER ASIDE OF HIS NOSE AND GIVING A NOD, HE DISAPPEARS IN A POUF OF RED AND GREEN GLITTER.

A FAINTLY ECHOING “HO HO HO” CAN BE HEARD AS THE SCREEN FADES TO BLACK.

-THE END-

The post The nightmare cruise before Christmas appeared first on Macleans.ca.


A lengthy queue snakes though Toronto's Yorkdale Mall as people wait to receive free COVID-19 rapid antigen test kits at a pop-up site at the shopping complex. (Chris Young/CP)

“You’re swearing a lot, Patricia,” a cousin recently observed. “I’ve been writing about the pandemic for nearly two years,” I responded, “It’s either a potty mouth or throwing something against a wall.”

If there is one issue that has amped up my vocabulary, it’s the slow rollout of rapid antigen tests (RATs) to the general population in this country, especially my home province of Ontario. I’ve been writing about rapid testing since December 2020 and only now, 515,000 cases of COVID, and 6,400 deaths later,  is the provincial government distributing some free home tests to everyone. No wonder #FreeTheRATs keeps trending on social media. 

The province says that “throughout December to mid-January, two million rapid tests will be provided free of charge at pop-up testing sites in high-traffic settings such as malls, retail settings, holiday markets, public libraries and transit hubs.” Given each pack contains five tests, that means just 400,000 packs for a population of 14.7 million, or one chance in 30 of scoring a free pack. (Maclean’s has asked Ontario’s Health Ministry to double check the number of tests and packs being given away.) 

The government touts how many tests have been distributed to workplaces—qualifying businesses get umpteen boxes of free rapid tests for their workers—and to students, who get five tests to use over the holidays. But if you don’t work for one of those businesses, or don’t have school-aged children, then the only way to get tests is to line up, or buy them through the private market, paying anywhere from $10 to $40 a test, if they are able to find them. Bear in mind these tests should be done every few days, or immediately before each gathering, to identify someone while they are infectious. At those prices, the costs are beyond the budgets of many Canadian families, and a tangible example of the deep inequities exposed by this pandemic. 

On Wednesday, as word spread on social media that free rapid tests were being handed out in Ontario, a Hunger Games race began: people rushed to the handful of locales, only to find they’d run out hours before. The next day, long lines formed early at the few pick-up locations, which quickly exhausted their supplies. Currently, there are few locations outside the Greater Toronto Area, prompting more frustration. 

The temporary holiday measures just unveiled in Ontario are miserly compared to Nova Scotia’s rapid testing strategy, now more than a year old. It has numerous testing sites (run by volunteers who have been trained by health-care professionals) and a new giveaway plan that saw 400,000 tests handed out in one day for a population of fewer than one million people. Some version of “Why can’t we do that?!?” is the most common reaction that Dr. Kevin Wilson, an epidemiologist in Halifax, hears from people outside of Nova Scotia about his province’s program. Roughly once a week, he drops into one of those sites to get a test before going to the gym or a big gathering. 

Making rapid testing both routine and normal is a key aspect to the Nova Scotia program. “If people want to keep things open, the only way to safely do that with a virus that spreads without symptoms is to do regular testing. Full stop,” said Dr. Lisa Barrett, the  infectious diseases researcher at Dalhousie University in Halifax, who helped start Canada’s first rapid testing pop-up sites in late November 2020. “[It’s] not to make cases low [that] you get tested, but to keep cases low,” Barrett explains.

The delays and difficulties surrounding the rollout of rapid tests in Ontario feels emblematic of the frustrations endured by many across this country during this pandemic. We’ve struggled to get PCR tests. We were so confused by government vaccine appointment systems that a group of volunteers started Vaccine Hunters Canada to help us. Then there is the cruelty endured by parents and their school-aged kids as they were repeatedly thrown into what colleague Shannon Proudfoot called the “dystopian hell” of online learning. What made the latter so utterly exasperating is that rapid testing could have prevented some school closures by identifying and isolating infectious students before they passed COVID-19 to their schoolmates. 

Indeed, the benefits of rapid testing in keeping community spread low have been clear for a long time. In the autumn of 2020, virtually the entire nation of Slovakia was tested two to three times in quick succession with rapid tests. Some 50,000 tests coming back positive, meaning a positivity rate of around four per cent. A week after the tests were done, case loads dropped by 60 per cent. In Europe, rapid tests are either free or ridiculously cheap, costing a dollar or two per test.

Except for Nova Scotia, provincial governments decided not to adopt the European model and incorporate rapid tests within their public health measures for the general population. As a result, even though provinces pressed Ottawa to buy and send them tens of millions of rapid tests, they left most of them on shelves for much of 2021. So great was the number of unused tests that, in a classic example of federal-provincial passive aggressiveness, Ottawa created a webpage detailing how many tests had been sent to each province, how many had been distributed and how many used. As of Dec. 15, Canada has received 99 million tests, of which 67 million have been deployed but just 15.5 million have been reported as used. In Ontario, fewer than one third of its tests have been used, according to the federal data. 

On Feb. 24, 2021, I wrote again about experts pressing for widespread rapid testing in Canada. “We are speaking of an infectious disease,” explained Dr. David Juncker, a biomedical engineering professor at McGill University in Montreal. “Yet our testing is all about detecting infected people, as opposed to detecting infectious people.” The advantage of rapid testing is that they can “be more efficient at stopping the pandemic” by identifying asymptomatic or pre-symptomatic people early, while they are infectious. 

That’s even more true now, as Delta is being pushed aside by the far more infectious Omicron as the dominant variant in Canada. The value of repeated testing can be seen in professional sports. For instance, though pretty much 100 per cent of the National Hockey League’s players are fully vaxxed, the league has already put at least 17 per cent of its players in its “COVID-19 protocol” this season thanks to its extensive testing program— something unavailable to most Canadians. (Even so, right now, the Calgary Flames has only five players eligible to play on its active roster.)

For much of December, it has felt like we are back at the end of 2020, and again, the Ontario government was a step or two behind the virus.. Case counts are rising quickly, this time because of Omicron, and Dr. Steini Brown of the Science Table warns “this will likely be the hardest wave of the pandemic.” Once again, it’s hard to get a PCR test in hard-hit areas. COVID-19 is once more sweeping through schools so quickly that boards are telling students to bring all their belongings home for the holidays, just in case.

And even though experts warned for months that the protection from just two doses of vaccine was waning; even though Health Canada authorized the use of Pfizer and Moderna boosters in early November, Ontario has given third doses of vaccine to fewer than 10 per cent of its population and is only now trying to ramp up its efforts. Last year, it delayed enacting public health restrictions until Boxing Day. This year, it only started distributing free rapid tests to the general population 10 days before Christmas.

Will Ontario continue to hand out free tests after the holidays? It depends how this rollout proceeds. The Ford government is sensitive to negative publicity, especially as there is an election coming in 2022, and images of lines of people queuing outside pop-up sites or provincially-run liquor stores may not be the happy holiday images they imagined.

On the flip side, if people take to social media to talk about how rapid testing contributed to them getting through the holidays at a time of explosive case growth, then  #FreeTheRATs may have proved its worth, and rapid tests for all will be made permanent.  

 

The post Ontario sees the value of rapid tests for COVID—as ever, way too late appeared first on Macleans.ca.


A lengthy queue snakes though Toronto's Yorkdale Mall as people wait to receive free COVID-19 rapid antigen test kits at a pop-up site at the shopping complex. (Chris Young/CP)

“You’re swearing a lot, Patricia,” a cousin recently observed. “I’ve been writing about the pandemic for nearly two years,” I responded, “It’s either a potty mouth or throwing something against a wall.”

If there is one issue that has amped up my vocabulary, it’s the slow rollout of rapid antigen tests (RATs) to the general population in this country, especially my home province of Ontario. I’ve been writing about rapid testing since December 2020 and only now, 515,000 cases of COVID, and 6,400 deaths later,  is the provincial government distributing some free home tests to everyone. No wonder #FreeTheRATs keeps trending on social media. 

The province says that “throughout December to mid-January, two million rapid tests will be provided free of charge at pop-up testing sites in high-traffic settings such as malls, retail settings, holiday markets, public libraries and transit hubs.” Given each pack contains five tests, that means just 400,000 packs for a population of 14.7 million, or one chance in 30 of scoring a free pack. (Maclean’s has asked Ontario’s Health Ministry to double check the number of tests and packs being given away.) 

The government touts how many tests have been distributed to workplaces—qualifying businesses get umpteen boxes of free rapid tests for their workers—and to students, who get five tests to use over the holidays. But if you don’t work for one of those businesses, or don’t have school-aged children, then the only way to get tests is to line up, or buy them through the private market, paying anywhere from $10 to $40 a test, if they are able to find them. Bear in mind these tests should be done every few days, or immediately before each gathering, to identify someone while they are infectious. At those prices, the costs are beyond the budgets of many Canadian families, and a tangible example of the deep inequities exposed by this pandemic. 

On Wednesday, as word spread on social media that free rapid tests were being handed out in Ontario, a Hunger Games race began: people rushed to the handful of locales, only to find they’d run out hours before. The next day, long lines formed early at the few pick-up locations, which quickly exhausted their supplies. Currently, there are few locations outside the Greater Toronto Area, prompting more frustration. 

The temporary holiday measures just unveiled in Ontario are miserly compared to Nova Scotia’s rapid testing strategy, now more than a year old. It has numerous testing sites (run by volunteers who have been trained by health-care professionals) and a new giveaway plan that saw 400,000 tests handed out in one day for a population of fewer than one million people. Some version of “Why can’t we do that?!?” is the most common reaction that Dr. Kevin Wilson, an epidemiologist in Halifax, hears from people outside of Nova Scotia about his province’s program. Roughly once a week, he drops into one of those sites to get a test before going to the gym or a big gathering. 

Making rapid testing both routine and normal is a key aspect to the Nova Scotia program. “If people want to keep things open, the only way to safely do that with a virus that spreads without symptoms is to do regular testing. Full stop,” said Dr. Lisa Barrett, the  infectious diseases researcher at Dalhousie University in Halifax, who helped start Canada’s first rapid testing pop-up sites in late November 2020. “[It’s] not to make cases low [that] you get tested, but to keep cases low,” Barrett explains.

The delays and difficulties surrounding the rollout of rapid tests in Ontario feels emblematic of the frustrations endured by many across this country during this pandemic. We’ve struggled to get PCR tests. We were so confused by government vaccine appointment systems that a group of volunteers started Vaccine Hunters Canada to help us. Then there is the cruelty endured by parents and their school-aged kids as they were repeatedly thrown into what colleague Shannon Proudfoot called the “dystopian hell” of online learning. What made the latter so utterly exasperating is that rapid testing could have prevented some school closures by identifying and isolating infectious students before they passed COVID-19 to their schoolmates. 

Indeed, the benefits of rapid testing in keeping community spread low have been clear for a long time. In the autumn of 2020, virtually the entire nation of Slovakia was tested two to three times in quick succession with rapid tests. Some 50,000 tests coming back positive, meaning a positivity rate of around four per cent. A week after the tests were done, case loads dropped by 60 per cent. In Europe, rapid tests are either free or ridiculously cheap, costing a dollar or two per test.

Except for Nova Scotia, provincial governments decided not to adopt the European model and incorporate rapid tests within their public health measures for the general population. As a result, even though provinces pressed Ottawa to buy and send them tens of millions of rapid tests, they left most of them on shelves for much of 2021. So great was the number of unused tests that, in a classic example of federal-provincial passive aggressiveness, Ottawa created a webpage detailing how many tests had been sent to each province, how many had been distributed and how many used. As of Dec. 15, Canada has received 99 million tests, of which 67 million have been deployed but just 15.5 million have been reported as used. In Ontario, fewer than one third of its tests have been used, according to the federal data. 

On Feb. 24, 2021, I wrote again about experts pressing for widespread rapid testing in Canada. “We are speaking of an infectious disease,” explained Dr. David Juncker, a biomedical engineering professor at McGill University in Montreal. “Yet our testing is all about detecting infected people, as opposed to detecting infectious people.” The advantage of rapid testing is that they can “be more efficient at stopping the pandemic” by identifying asymptomatic or pre-symptomatic people early, while they are infectious. 

That’s even more true now, as Delta is being pushed aside by the far more infectious Omicron as the dominant variant in Canada. The value of repeated testing can be seen in professional sports. For instance, though pretty much 100 per cent of the National Hockey League’s players are fully vaxxed, the league has already put at least 17 per cent of its players in its “COVID-19 protocol” this season thanks to its extensive testing program— something unavailable to most Canadians. (Even so, right now, the Calgary Flames has only five players eligible to play on its active roster.)

For much of December, it has felt like we are back at the end of 2020, and again, the Ontario government was a step or two behind the virus.. Case counts are rising quickly, this time because of Omicron, and Dr. Steini Brown of the Science Table warns “this will likely be the hardest wave of the pandemic.” Once again, it’s hard to get a PCR test in hard-hit areas. COVID-19 is once more sweeping through schools so quickly that boards are telling students to bring all their belongings home for the holidays, just in case.

And even though experts warned for months that the protection from just two doses of vaccine was waning; even though Health Canada authorized the use of Pfizer and Moderna boosters in early November, Ontario has given third doses of vaccine to fewer than 10 per cent of its population and is only now trying to ramp up its efforts. Last year, it delayed enacting public health restrictions until Boxing Day. This year, it only started distributing free rapid tests to the general population 10 days before Christmas.

Will Ontario continue to hand out free tests after the holidays? It depends how this rollout proceeds. The Ford government is sensitive to negative publicity, especially as there is an election coming in 2022, and images of lines of people queuing outside pop-up sites or provincially-run liquor stores may not be the happy holiday images they imagined.

On the flip side, if people take to social media to talk about how rapid testing contributed to them getting through the holidays at a time of explosive case growth, then  #FreeTheRATs may have proved its worth, and rapid tests for all will be made permanent.  

 

The post Ontario sees the value of rapid tests for COVID—as ever, way too late appeared first on Macleans.ca.


The pandemic has brought us no end of idioms, old and new, from “social distancing” to “covidiot.” Few, though, have served us as well as “the before times”—a bit of wistful shorthand for life before masks and border closures and denialist mobs who regard hospitals as symbols of state oppression.

The expression is a mainstay of apocalyptic sci-fi, whose origins are pleasingly on point. It’s been traced to a 1966 episode of the original Star Trek, in which the crew of the Enterprise encounters a planet full of children whose parents have been obliterated by a deadly pathogen; to them, the “before time” is a period when adults inhabited their world. Today, we use it for comic effect, as in: “Remember the before times? When we could sit inside a restaurant and eat brunch?”

But even a phrase used in jest can reveal something about our hopes and fears, and if we’re still resorting to words of longing in 2022, it is surely a sign of our shared anxiety about what lies ahead. Will we revert to some semblance of the old normal? Should we want to?

READ: Maclean’s meets the moment: Our new magazine look, explained 

In the movies, the survivors of global catastrophe emerge blinking in the daylight to build a new society, leaving behind the problems of the old one. But look around Canada in 2022 and it’s pretty clear that’s not in the cards; the great challenges facing it before the pandemic haven’t gone away. Reconciliation with Indigenous peoples remains an unfulfilled aspiration. Our biggest trading partner, the U.S., seems indifferent to its commitments under the “new” NAFTA. Our second-biggest, China, is also our greatest international antagonist.

Most importantly, the country remains riven over the challenge of addressing climate change, committed to reducing greenhouse gas emissions to 45 per cent below 2005 levels within a decade, even as construction continues on pipelines to carry oil and gas to tidewater.

None of these issues lies beyond our capacity for creative solutions. And Canada appears uniquely poised to thrive in a post-pandemic world: its resources, educated population and stable government point to a future as a rich country whose prosperity arises from economic liberty, plurality and rule of law.

But as the pandemic recedes, new faults and barriers come into view. The polarization of our politics has accelerated, dividing our electorate by region, values and identity, to the point that one major party appears hopelessly fractured, and another governs with just 32.6 per cent of the popular vote, the least for a winner in Canadian history.

READ: How the pandemic has rewired our brains 

Not coincidentally, political extremism has migrated from the swamps of the web to the mainstream, breathing life into a party that disparages immigrants and denies science. Technology has abetted these forces, transmitting the lies that are the extremists’ currency, while undermining the principle of privacy on which freedom rests.

All of this has occurred amid a growing awareness of atrocity that lies at the centre of our founding myths as a country. If truth and reconciliation are part of a continuum, we’re only beginning to come to grips with the first piece, truth, symbolized by unmarked graves of Indigenous children who died while attending residential schools.

Yet truth, painful as it can be, is an answer unto itself. This might be the greatest takeaway of the last two years: when our scientists publicly shared their findings; when our public health agencies published data showing the extent of danger; when our politicians left the varnish off their words and acted on evidence, the vast majority of us took our cues, masking up, staying home, getting vaccinated. In doing so, we avoided the worst COVID-19 could bring.

Here lies the solution to the conspiracy theories infecting our politics; to the devastation inflicted on First Nations; to the fantasy that we can fight climate change while building a fossil fuel economy. Let’s renew our shared commitment to what we know to be true, to what can be proven.

The sooner we get going, the better. We can start with the following hard and necessary truth: “the before times” are not coming back.

A selection of stories from our Year Ahead issue:


This editorial appears in print in the January 2022 issue of Maclean’s magazine. Subscribe to the monthly print magazine here.

The post After the ‘before times,’ but before the times that come afterwards appeared first on Macleans.ca.


The pandemic has brought us no end of idioms, old and new, from “social distancing” to “covidiot.” Few, though, have served us as well as “the before times”—a bit of wistful shorthand for life before masks and border closures and denialist mobs who regard hospitals as symbols of state oppression.

The expression is a mainstay of apocalyptic sci-fi, whose origins are pleasingly on point. It’s been traced to a 1966 episode of the original Star Trek, in which the crew of the Enterprise encounters a planet full of children whose parents have been obliterated by a deadly pathogen; to them, the “before time” is a period when adults inhabited their world. Today, we use it for comic effect, as in: “Remember the before times? When we could sit inside a restaurant and eat brunch?”

But even a phrase used in jest can reveal something about our hopes and fears, and if we’re still resorting to words of longing in 2022, it is surely a sign of our shared anxiety about what lies ahead. Will we revert to some semblance of the old normal? Should we want to?

READ: Maclean’s meets the moment: Our new magazine look, explained 

In the movies, the survivors of global catastrophe emerge blinking in the daylight to build a new society, leaving behind the problems of the old one. But look around Canada in 2022 and it’s pretty clear that’s not in the cards; the great challenges facing it before the pandemic haven’t gone away. Reconciliation with Indigenous peoples remains an unfulfilled aspiration. Our biggest trading partner, the U.S., seems indifferent to its commitments under the “new” NAFTA. Our second-biggest, China, is also our greatest international antagonist.

Most importantly, the country remains riven over the challenge of addressing climate change, committed to reducing greenhouse gas emissions to 45 per cent below 2005 levels within a decade, even as construction continues on pipelines to carry oil and gas to tidewater.

None of these issues lies beyond our capacity for creative solutions. And Canada appears uniquely poised to thrive in a post-pandemic world: its resources, educated population and stable government point to a future as a rich country whose prosperity arises from economic liberty, plurality and rule of law.

But as the pandemic recedes, new faults and barriers come into view. The polarization of our politics has accelerated, dividing our electorate by region, values and identity, to the point that one major party appears hopelessly fractured, and another governs with just 32.6 per cent of the popular vote, the least for a winner in Canadian history.

READ: How the pandemic has rewired our brains 

Not coincidentally, political extremism has migrated from the swamps of the web to the mainstream, breathing life into a party that disparages immigrants and denies science. Technology has abetted these forces, transmitting the lies that are the extremists’ currency, while undermining the principle of privacy on which freedom rests.

All of this has occurred amid a growing awareness of atrocity that lies at the centre of our founding myths as a country. If truth and reconciliation are part of a continuum, we’re only beginning to come to grips with the first piece, truth, symbolized by unmarked graves of Indigenous children who died while attending residential schools.

Yet truth, painful as it can be, is an answer unto itself. This might be the greatest takeaway of the last two years: when our scientists publicly shared their findings; when our public health agencies published data showing the extent of danger; when our politicians left the varnish off their words and acted on evidence, the vast majority of us took our cues, masking up, staying home, getting vaccinated. In doing so, we avoided the worst COVID-19 could bring.

Here lies the solution to the conspiracy theories infecting our politics; to the devastation inflicted on First Nations; to the fantasy that we can fight climate change while building a fossil fuel economy. Let’s renew our shared commitment to what we know to be true, to what can be proven.

The sooner we get going, the better. We can start with the following hard and necessary truth: “the before times” are not coming back.

A selection of stories from our Year Ahead issue:


This editorial appears in print in the January 2022 issue of Maclean’s magazine. Subscribe to the monthly print magazine here.

The post What our longing for the ‘before times’ reveals about our hopes and fears for 2022 appeared first on Macleans.ca.


Gov. Gen. Mary Simon, with Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, delivers the Throne Speech in the Senate in Ottawa on Nov. 23, 2021 (Sean Kilpatrick/CP)

It’s not often that a Throne Speech has made me hit pause and rewind. This week’s, like many others before it, was packed with dull pageantry and endless platitudes—“go further, faster”, “no worker or region will be left behind”, “build back better”. There was nothing glaringly out of the ordinary about the speech either, except the fact that it was delivered in three languages by Canada’s first Indigenous Governor General.

But then there was this one tiny tidbit: “A changing world requires adapting and expanding diplomatic engagement.”

For foreign policy wonks, it was like an oasis in the desert. Could it be? After decades of neglect, could a Canadian government at last be waking up to the fact that Canada’s foreign service is in crisis? Or is it just another Liberal government mirage?

The statement didn’t actually commit to “adapting and expanding” the foreign service, though one presumes more diplomatic engagement means more foreign service. And more may sound nice, but in and of itself it is not a solution, in the same way throwing money at a problem may not produce the intended results.

But let’s pretend for a moment that the Liberals may indeed be planning a serious foreign policy overhaul. What would it look like?

According to Daniel Livermore, a retired diplomat and senior fellow at the University of Ottawa’s Public and International Affairs department, more doesn’t mean more money. “The problem isn’t funding,” he wrote in February last year.  “It’s [Global Affair’s] byzantine structure and management incompetence, which defy almost any modern precepts of public administration. Mismanagement of human resources for two decades has destroyed much of the Canadian foreign service, and GAC now finds itself weak on analytical capacity, woefully lacking in linguistic and regional expertise, and virtually incapacitated by a propensity for endless meetings, consultations and discussions, where issues are talked to death without decisions.”

Staffing shortages, Livermore tells me, have left embassies scrambling to fill positions. “You can’t develop competence when you’re constantly trying to cover gaps at missions,” he says. “Ideally, you would have a Russia expert stationed in Moscow, and then re-assigned to eastern Europe and then maybe sent to Brussels or the UN. There needs to be continuity and a logic to how postings develop a person’s skills. Instead, you have an agriculture expert suddenly posted to an embassy in a major capital where Canada has no agricultural interests, simply because that embassy is short-staffed.”

The world is complicated, and becoming more so every day. A foreign service staffed by people with a passion for the work they do, and the skills needed to do the job well, is more important now that has been since the Cold War. The Global Security Reporting Program (GSRP) is a fascinating model, developed in response to the attacks on Sept. 11, 2001 to quickly adapt to a world that had suddenly changed. The goal then was to send the most talented diplomats, the ones who possessed the language skills and creative thinking to dive deep into their postings, to regions of particular strategic interest to Canada.

These were, theoretically, the top guns of the foreign service. As one GSRP officer once told me, their job was “intelligence gathering by other means”—i.e., all open source—which meant going out beyond the blast walls and concertina wire surrounding diplomatic compounds and engaging with “unusual suspects.”

The program has had its challenges, not least of which was an institutional clash with CSIS, which accused GSRP officers of treading on its territory. But it has survived and remains a powerful tool in Canada’s foreign policy toolkit.

It was the GSRP, for instance, that exposed Canada’s disastrous strategy in Iraq in 2016 under the leadership of Ambassador Bruno Saccomani, Stephen Harper’s former bodyguard.  The Liberals were able to change course because GSRP officers spoke up.

Since then, the world has changed again. The War on Terror has failed; the U.S. has spectacularly lost the war in Afghanistan; the U.S.-led world order is fragmenting into a multipolar free-for-all premised on transactionalism and increasingly led by authoritarians; and climate-related disasters, with all their attendant consequences (starvation, migration, war), are on the rise.

Canada, meanwhile, has not carried out an extensive foreign policy review in more than half a century (the last one was ordered by Justin Trudeau’s father in 1968). Over its six years in power, the Liberal government has appointed six foreign ministers, including an astronaut, a businessperson, and now a commercial lawyer. Only the businessperson makes any modicum of sense, though his previous posting as trade minister was more in his lane. Shifting him to foreign minister only demonstrated that the Trudeau Liberals still clung to the fantasy that a trade-based foreign policy would somehow produce a better world, or at least a better world for Canada. China put the kibosh to that foolish notion.

So, what then would “adapting and expanding” look like? A foreign policy review is obviously the bare minimum, though Livermore is skeptical of the impact such a review could have. “We already know what the problems are,” he says. “Doubling the number of GSRP officers would help, but it wouldn’t solve the problem either. The GSRP is a specialized program looking at economic and security issues. What’s needed is a major overhaul of how human resources are handled at Global Affairs. The foreign service has been decimated over the last two decades. It will take years to rebuild it.”

Back in 2016, Sven Jurschewsky, one of the architects of the GSRP, lamented the sorry state of affairs at the foreign service, which he said had become such a bureaucratized mess that it had ceased to attract talented people. He hailed from a much more romantic diplomatic past, from the Kenneth D. Taylor generation and the Canada Caper. He idolized men like Peter Bakewell, the Canadian diplomat in Communist Prague who risked his life to help Charter 77 dissidents.

“Being a diplomat used to mean something back then,” he told me. “We were engaged with the world, and we believed deeply in what we were doing. These days, too many diplomats … reach their positions by keeping their heads down and not causing any waves. Those types should not be in leadership positions. They’ve created a culture of incompetence that is driving away the best talent at the bottom. And I’m telling you: Canada will suffer for it.”

Sadly, Jurschewsky passed away in 2018. I have no doubt he would have rolled his eyes at this week’s Throne Speech—he was never one for pomp and circumstance, and platitudes made him bristly. But like so many other former diplomats, he may have perked up at even the intimation of a more robust foreign service. For those who have been out in the world, Canada has lost its way, and there is growing concern over whether it will ever find its way back.

The post Did the Liberals just promise a better foreign policy? appeared first on Macleans.ca.


Gov. Gen. Mary Simon, with Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, delivers the Throne Speech in the Senate in Ottawa on Nov. 23, 2021 (Sean Kilpatrick/CP)

It’s not often that a Throne Speech has made me hit pause and rewind. This week’s, like many others before it, was packed with dull pageantry and endless platitudes—“go further, faster”, “no worker or region will be left behind”, “build back better”. There was nothing glaringly out of the ordinary about the speech either, except the fact that it was delivered in three languages by Canada’s first Indigenous Governor General.

But then there was this one tiny tidbit: “A changing world requires adapting and expanding diplomatic engagement.”

For foreign policy wonks, it was like an oasis in the desert. Could it be? After decades of neglect, could a Canadian government at last be waking up to the fact that Canada’s foreign service is in crisis? Or is it just another Liberal government mirage?

The statement didn’t actually commit to “adapting and expanding” the foreign service, though one presumes more diplomatic engagement means more foreign service. And more may sound nice, but in and of itself it is not a solution, in the same way throwing money at a problem may not produce the intended results.

But let’s pretend for a moment that the Liberals may indeed be planning a serious foreign policy overhaul. What would it look like?

According to Daniel Livermore, a retired diplomat and senior fellow at the University of Ottawa’s Public and International Affairs department, more doesn’t mean more money. “The problem isn’t funding,” he wrote in February last year.  “It’s [Global Affair’s] byzantine structure and management incompetence, which defy almost any modern precepts of public administration. Mismanagement of human resources for two decades has destroyed much of the Canadian foreign service, and GAC now finds itself weak on analytical capacity, woefully lacking in linguistic and regional expertise, and virtually incapacitated by a propensity for endless meetings, consultations and discussions, where issues are talked to death without decisions.”

Staffing shortages, Livermore tells me, have left embassies scrambling to fill positions. “You can’t develop competence when you’re constantly trying to cover gaps at missions,” he says. “Ideally, you would have a Russia expert stationed in Moscow, and then re-assigned to eastern Europe and then maybe sent to Brussels or the UN. There needs to be continuity and a logic to how postings develop a person’s skills. Instead, you have an agriculture expert suddenly posted to an embassy in a major capital where Canada has no agricultural interests, simply because that embassy is short-staffed.”

The world is complicated, and becoming more so every day. A foreign service staffed by people with a passion for the work they do, and the skills needed to do the job well, is more important now that has been since the Cold War. The Global Security Reporting Program (GSRP) is a fascinating model, developed in response to the attacks on Sept. 11, 2001 to quickly adapt to a world that had suddenly changed. The goal then was to send the most talented diplomats, the ones who possessed the language skills and creative thinking to dive deep into their postings, to regions of particular strategic interest to Canada.

These were, theoretically, the top guns of the foreign service. As one GSRP officer once told me, their job was “intelligence gathering by other means”—i.e., all open source—which meant going out beyond the blast walls and concertina wire surrounding diplomatic compounds and engaging with “unusual suspects.”

The program has had its challenges, not least of which was an institutional clash with CSIS, which accused GSRP officers of treading on its territory. But it has survived and remains a powerful tool in Canada’s foreign policy toolkit.

It was the GSRP, for instance, that exposed Canada’s disastrous strategy in Iraq in 2016 under the leadership of Ambassador Bruno Saccomani, Stephen Harper’s former bodyguard.  The Liberals were able to change course because GSRP officers spoke up.

Since then, the world has changed again. The War on Terror has failed; the U.S. has spectacularly lost the war in Afghanistan; the U.S.-led world order is fragmenting into a multipolar free-for-all premised on transactionalism and increasingly led by authoritarians; and climate-related disasters, with all their attendant consequences (starvation, migration, war), are on the rise.

Canada, meanwhile, has not carried out an extensive foreign policy review in more than half a century (the last one was ordered by Justin Trudeau’s father in 1968). Over its six years in power, the Liberal government has appointed six foreign ministers, including an astronaut, a businessperson, and now a commercial lawyer. Only the businessperson makes any modicum of sense, though his previous posting as trade minister was more in his lane. Shifting him to foreign minister only demonstrated that the Trudeau Liberals still clung to the fantasy that a trade-based foreign policy would somehow produce a better world, or at least a better world for Canada. China put the kibosh to that foolish notion.

So, what then would “adapting and expanding” look like? A foreign policy review is obviously the bare minimum, though Livermore is skeptical of the impact such a review could have. “We already know what the problems are,” he says. “Doubling the number of GSRP officers would help, but it wouldn’t solve the problem either. The GSRP is a specialized program looking at economic and security issues. What’s needed is a major overhaul of how human resources are handled at Global Affairs. The foreign service has been decimated over the last two decades. It will take years to rebuild it.”

Back in 2016, Sven Jurschewsky, one of the architects of the GSRP, lamented the sorry state of affairs at the foreign service, which he said had become such a bureaucratized mess that it had ceased to attract talented people. He hailed from a much more romantic diplomatic past, from the Kenneth D. Taylor generation and the Canada Caper. He idolized men like Peter Bakewell, the Canadian diplomat in Communist Prague who risked his life to help Charter 77 dissidents.

“Being a diplomat used to mean something back then,” he told me. “We were engaged with the world, and we believed deeply in what we were doing. These days, too many diplomats … reach their positions by keeping their heads down and not causing any waves. Those types should not be in leadership positions. They’ve created a culture of incompetence that is driving away the best talent at the bottom. And I’m telling you: Canada will suffer for it.”

Sadly, Jurschewsky passed away in 2018. I have no doubt he would have rolled his eyes at this week’s Throne Speech—he was never one for pomp and circumstance, and platitudes made him bristly. But like so many other former diplomats, he may have perked up at even the intimation of a more robust foreign service. For those who have been out in the world, Canada has lost its way, and there is growing concern over whether it will ever find its way back.

The post Did the Liberals just promise a better foreign policy? appeared first on Macleans.ca.


Baby talk

In October, Joanna Long told the story of her family’s experience with embryo donation

Perhaps an editor can explain the tabloid headline on the cover of the October issue (“Here, take my baby,” October 2021). I wonder how the families featured in the article feel, given such a disrespectful headline? The donation of embryos is not equivalent to the donation of babies. This ridiculous language only serves to further inflame the questions around reproductive rights in Canada. I wonder if your cover language will result in fewer embryo donors, most certainly not a goal of the families who opened up their lives to your magazine. Joanna Long’s actual article is thorough and thoughtful and does an outstanding job of addressing the rewards and challenges of embryo donation and adoption. In fact, the article makes it clear that the embryo donors do not perceive themselves to be “parents” of the children who grew from those embryos.

—Amy Witt, Salmon Arm, B.C.

I’ve had to walk myself around how to comment on this cover several times, because it’s so enraging. So, leaving aside all my fury, here it is: the cover is inaccurate, misleading and astoundingly tone-deaf, given the renewed battle for women’s right to choose—especially in the States. The wonderful people who donated something to a childless couple were so generous, thoughtful and kind. It all seems to have worked out for the best—and kudos to both couples, and others like them. And bad cess to Maclean’s for fouling this. What was donated was not a “baby.” It wasn’t even a fetus. It was an embryo. I’ve been active in the women’s movement since the mid-’70s and what got me involved in the first place was Otto Lang’s statement about “this silly slogan that a woman has the right to control her own body.” And we are still battling people who want to have arbitrary control over a woman’s choice, a woman’s body, all these years later. This is not a battle for values or opinions or beliefs. Believe what you will. It’s a battle for rights. Our rights. Don’t foul the waters any more than they have been already, Maclean’s.

—Kathleen Kilburn, Redbridge, Ont.

Where credit’s due

After the September federal election, Paul Wells wrote about Justin Trudeau’s broken triumph

I’m not sure we can judge the solvency and merit of a country and its leader during a global pandemic, but in Paul Wells’s article, he writes that campaigns “discourage serious work while they’re looming” (“The triumph of Justin Trudeau,” November 2021). Considering the past 19 months of this never-ending pandemic, I doubt any of us would black-mark the Prime Minister and his team for procuring mega quantities of vaccine and personal protective equipment, and for providing ongoing financial support to people without jobs, who were told to stay home, and overextended provinces. These months have demanded on-the-spot governance and strategic focus despite a looming election. In my mind, Justin Trudeau was able to do both. Election campaigns keep democracies on track by reminding candidates what matters to the soul of the country, but I agree with Mr. Wells that the next one will be far too soon.

—Catherine Hammill, Kincardine, Ont.

Proletarian blues

Shannon Proudfoot wrote about how the working class—a once undervalued and ignored group—is fighting back. 

When are the media and unions going to stop referring to only union members and low-paid people as “the working class” (“The working class has had enough,” October 2021). Didn’t the rest of us who were not union members and who weren’t poorly paid but had jobs also work? It’s time to change the terminology.

—Alistair Shearer, Toronto

Waning winter

John Streicker, climate scientist and Yukon minister, went neck-deep into freezing waters in October to show rising water levels

Good article about climate change (“John Streicker on rapid snowmelt, and why he got into it up to his neck,” The Moment, November 2021). This type of thing is happening everywhere, but our politicians are doing nothing about it. I live in Ontario’s Simcoe County and love cross-country skiing. Fifteen years ago, my average ski season was from the second week of December to the second week in April (the snow takes a while to melt in the bush). Now, it’s from the first week of January to the last week of March. Owners of the local resorts have been complaining that the seasons are so short now, it’s not worth continuing to run their businesses. It’s ironic that our governments are so business-oriented and yet are willing to see a huge portion collapse.

—Clayton Donoghue, Barrie, Ont.

Narwhals and noise

In October, Bill Donahue told the story of how Arctic narwhal are being threatened by the sound of passing ships. 

Another endangered Arctic species to add to a growing list (“The sound of too much noise,” October 2021). Does anyone think there is hope for wildlife on this planet when humans exploit any area to extract minerals, oil and assorted other products to continue living a life of excess consumption?

—John Orange, Barrie, Ont.

The technology is out there to eliminate the ship noise disturbing the narwhals. Royal Canadian Navy coastal patrol vessels built in the late 1990s have electric propellers; batteries are recharged by small diesel motors above water level. The ships are quiet enough that dolphins regularly join them to surf in their bow waves. Time to restrict Canada’s waters to electric-propelled ships?

—Ardell Ramage, Nanaimo, B.C.

Leaping lizards

In September, Anthony A. Davis delved into the wall lizard invasion of Vancouver Island. 

Around 10 years ago, I tried to warn people that the invasive wall lizards were extirpating the native field cricket on the Saanich Peninsula, where I had moved my herd of dairy goats in 2008 (“Climbing the walls,” Bearings, October 2021). As a lifelong naturalist, as well as a farmer for decades, I noticed that as the lizard numbers increased, the crickets decreased. Each summer, fewer and fewer crickets sang in the dry grasses. Finally, this year, the hill fell silent as the last cricket vanished. By that point the lizard population was truly phenomenal; walking through a field in the afternoon one felt like Moses parting the Red Sea as waves of lizards ran away. I began asking anybody who had told me they had the lizards in their area when they’d last heard a field cricket singing, and every single person told me they couldn’t remember. Wild voices are falling silent, and people, inside their particle-board houses with their televisions and electronic gadgets blaring, don’t notice.

—Willi Boepple, Victoria

I was surprised to see our wee wall lizards in Maclean’s. I love mine, with ants now completely eradicated from my property in Greater Victoria. My wall lizards are wonderful listeners as long as you don’t make any sudden moves. One time, a friend and I sat on my patio talking, and along came a wall lizard that perched on the nearby step and cocked its head, listening intently. “Gosh,” said my friend, “I hope he isn’t going to try to sell me some insurance.”

—Toni Blodgett, Victoria

Daylight blight

In October, Shannon Proudfoot laid out the pros and cons of Daylight Saving Time

In the list of “cons” cited in the article about daylight saving, the only dangerous negative mentioned is the increase in car accidents (“Daylight saving time,” The Debate, October 2021). There are other dangers. A study from Sweden’s Karolinska Institute reported in the New England Journal of Medicine in 2008 found there was a five per cent increase in heart attacks in the week following the switch. In 2009, a study published in the Journal of Applied Psychology showed that on the Monday after the springtime switch, workers in mines sustained more injuries of greater severity. Clearly, daylight saving is past its best-before date.

—Morley Lertzman, North Vancouver, B.C.

***

Bike sleuth

The November issue featured the story of Canada’s lone bike-theft detective.

Poor guy. All of Canada can only put resources together for one full-time officer. Must feel like a losing battle.

—Gray Staniforth on Facebook

Just goes to show one person can make a difference. Just think outside the box, try a little harder and collaborate with others where you’re weak.

—Zerah Smith on Facebook

Unbothered

Shannon Proudfoot, in our last issue, put a voice to a frustrated country unimpressed with an ill-timed election. Not everyone shared that view.

The public never snapped, they mostly marched out and voted as usual, a bit grumpy. But if they’d snapped you’d have a new govt.

—@EDenhoff on Twitter

I’ve seen a number of articles telling me how mad I am. My friends and I haven’t talked about the election or Trudeau for weeks. We’re talking about the trips we want to take.

—Teri Jones on Facebook

The post ‘The donation of embryos is not equivalent to the donation of babies’ appeared first on Macleans.ca.


Baby talk

In October, Joanna Long told the story of her family’s experience with embryo donation

Perhaps an editor can explain the tabloid headline on the cover of the October issue (“Here, take my baby,” October 2021). I wonder how the families featured in the article feel, given such a disrespectful headline? The donation of embryos is not equivalent to the donation of babies. This ridiculous language only serves to further inflame the questions around reproductive rights in Canada. I wonder if your cover language will result in fewer embryo donors, most certainly not a goal of the families who opened up their lives to your magazine. Joanna Long’s actual article is thorough and thoughtful and does an outstanding job of addressing the rewards and challenges of embryo donation and adoption. In fact, the article makes it clear that the embryo donors do not perceive themselves to be “parents” of the children who grew from those embryos.

—Amy Witt, Salmon Arm, B.C.

I’ve had to walk myself around how to comment on this cover several times, because it’s so enraging. So, leaving aside all my fury, here it is: the cover is inaccurate, misleading and astoundingly tone-deaf, given the renewed battle for women’s right to choose—especially in the States. The wonderful people who donated something to a childless couple were so generous, thoughtful and kind. It all seems to have worked out for the best—and kudos to both couples, and others like them. And bad cess to Maclean’s for fouling this. What was donated was not a “baby.” It wasn’t even a fetus. It was an embryo. I’ve been active in the women’s movement since the mid-’70s and what got me involved in the first place was Otto Lang’s statement about “this silly slogan that a woman has the right to control her own body.” And we are still battling people who want to have arbitrary control over a woman’s choice, a woman’s body, all these years later. This is not a battle for values or opinions or beliefs. Believe what you will. It’s a battle for rights. Our rights. Don’t foul the waters any more than they have been already, Maclean’s.

—Kathleen Kilburn, Redbridge, Ont.

Where credit’s due

After the September federal election, Paul Wells wrote about Justin Trudeau’s broken triumph

I’m not sure we can judge the solvency and merit of a country and its leader during a global pandemic, but in Paul Wells’s article, he writes that campaigns “discourage serious work while they’re looming” (“The triumph of Justin Trudeau,” November 2021). Considering the past 19 months of this never-ending pandemic, I doubt any of us would black-mark the Prime Minister and his team for procuring mega quantities of vaccine and personal protective equipment, and for providing ongoing financial support to people without jobs, who were told to stay home, and overextended provinces. These months have demanded on-the-spot governance and strategic focus despite a looming election. In my mind, Justin Trudeau was able to do both. Election campaigns keep democracies on track by reminding candidates what matters to the soul of the country, but I agree with Mr. Wells that the next one will be far too soon.

—Catherine Hammill, Kincardine, Ont.

Proletarian blues

Shannon Proudfoot wrote about how the working class—a once undervalued and ignored group—is fighting back. 

When are the media and unions going to stop referring to only union members and low-paid people as “the working class” (“The working class has had enough,” October 2021). Didn’t the rest of us who were not union members and who weren’t poorly paid but had jobs also work? It’s time to change the terminology.

—Alistair Shearer, Toronto

Waning winter

John Streicker, climate scientist and Yukon minister, went neck-deep into freezing waters in October to show rising water levels

Good article about climate change (“John Streicker on rapid snowmelt, and why he got into it up to his neck,” The Moment, November 2021). This type of thing is happening everywhere, but our politicians are doing nothing about it. I live in Ontario’s Simcoe County and love cross-country skiing. Fifteen years ago, my average ski season was from the second week of December to the second week in April (the snow takes a while to melt in the bush). Now, it’s from the first week of January to the last week of March. Owners of the local resorts have been complaining that the seasons are so short now, it’s not worth continuing to run their businesses. It’s ironic that our governments are so business-oriented and yet are willing to see a huge portion collapse.

—Clayton Donoghue, Barrie, Ont.

Narwhals and noise

In October, Bill Donahue told the story of how Arctic narwhal are being threatened by the sound of passing ships. 

Another endangered Arctic species to add to a growing list (“The sound of too much noise,” October 2021). Does anyone think there is hope for wildlife on this planet when humans exploit any area to extract minerals, oil and assorted other products to continue living a life of excess consumption?

—John Orange, Barrie, Ont.

The technology is out there to eliminate the ship noise disturbing the narwhals. Royal Canadian Navy coastal patrol vessels built in the late 1990s have electric propellers; batteries are recharged by small diesel motors above water level. The ships are quiet enough that dolphins regularly join them to surf in their bow waves. Time to restrict Canada’s waters to electric-propelled ships?

—Ardell Ramage, Nanaimo, B.C.

Leaping lizards

In September, Anthony A. Davis delved into the wall lizard invasion of Vancouver Island. 

Around 10 years ago, I tried to warn people that the invasive wall lizards were extirpating the native field cricket on the Saanich Peninsula, where I had moved my herd of dairy goats in 2008 (“Climbing the walls,” Bearings, October 2021). As a lifelong naturalist, as well as a farmer for decades, I noticed that as the lizard numbers increased, the crickets decreased. Each summer, fewer and fewer crickets sang in the dry grasses. Finally, this year, the hill fell silent as the last cricket vanished. By that point the lizard population was truly phenomenal; walking through a field in the afternoon one felt like Moses parting the Red Sea as waves of lizards ran away. I began asking anybody who had told me they had the lizards in their area when they’d last heard a field cricket singing, and every single person told me they couldn’t remember. Wild voices are falling silent, and people, inside their particle-board houses with their televisions and electronic gadgets blaring, don’t notice.

—Willi Boepple, Victoria

I was surprised to see our wee wall lizards in Maclean’s. I love mine, with ants now completely eradicated from my property in Greater Victoria. My wall lizards are wonderful listeners as long as you don’t make any sudden moves. One time, a friend and I sat on my patio talking, and along came a wall lizard that perched on the nearby step and cocked its head, listening intently. “Gosh,” said my friend, “I hope he isn’t going to try to sell me some insurance.”

—Toni Blodgett, Victoria

Daylight blight

In October, Shannon Proudfoot laid out the pros and cons of Daylight Saving Time

In the list of “cons” cited in the article about daylight saving, the only dangerous negative mentioned is the increase in car accidents (“Daylight saving time,” The Debate, October 2021). There are other dangers. A study from Sweden’s Karolinska Institute reported in the New England Journal of Medicine in 2008 found there was a five per cent increase in heart attacks in the week following the switch. In 2009, a study published in the Journal of Applied Psychology showed that on the Monday after the springtime switch, workers in mines sustained more injuries of greater severity. Clearly, daylight saving is past its best-before date.

—Morley Lertzman, North Vancouver, B.C.

***

Bike sleuth

The November issue featured the story of Canada’s lone bike-theft detective.

Poor guy. All of Canada can only put resources together for one full-time officer. Must feel like a losing battle.

—Gray Staniforth on Facebook

Just goes to show one person can make a difference. Just think outside the box, try a little harder and collaborate with others where you’re weak.

—Zerah Smith on Facebook

Unbothered

Shannon Proudfoot, in our last issue, put a voice to a frustrated country unimpressed with an ill-timed election. Not everyone shared that view.

The public never snapped, they mostly marched out and voted as usual, a bit grumpy. But if they’d snapped you’d have a new govt.

—@EDenhoff on Twitter

I’ve seen a number of articles telling me how mad I am. My friends and I haven’t talked about the election or Trudeau for weeks. We’re talking about the trips we want to take.

—Teri Jones on Facebook

The post ‘The donation of embryos is not equivalent to the donation of babies’ appeared first on Macleans.ca.