LP_468x60
ontario news watch
on-the-record-468x60-white
and-another-thing-468x60

Over the years I've learned to expect crippling, crushing and constant letdowns when it comes to Canadian politics.  On every level.  Even your political opponents can be counted on to behave in such a boneheaded and amateur-hour fashion that somehow, you end up disappointed in them.

You see, I expected that left-populism would come to Canada.  Why, I even predicted it on this here website.  I didn't want it, to be clear, but I knew it would become a thing, and I thought I'd prepared myself accordingly.

I dared to dream that the long-awaited left-wing deliverer would be a Canadian Alexandra Ocasio-Cortez, plucked from the ranks of the burgeoning youth movement against conservative politics, or perhaps some rookie provincial representative elected in Ontario, PEI, Quebec, or Alberta.  An honest to goodness bottom-up resistance would result, and be, in the long run, a good thing for our country, bringing fresh blood into the political arena and forcing our crochety multi-party consensus to adapt.

And then, all of a sudden, our media cut any hope of change off at the knees by anointing everybody's favourite slightly dotty aunt, Elizabeth May, as the heir apparent.  It is hereby decreed, by all the seasoned advisors and venerable pollsters, that the Greens are ascendant in Canadian politics!  Look out, traditional parties, because Canadians are "preoccupied!"  They're actually taking a second look at May despite the loony things she says.  This is not a drill, people!

Conservative-adjacent media folk immediately took to social media to drive the Israel wedge, but May already did the work for them by booting Holocaust denier Monika Schaefer and conspiracy-spinner Dmitri Lascaris from her fold.  Green figureheads such as Mike Schreiner in Ontario have successfully blunted the charge of having crazy and threatening radical views by being so dull that they make John Tory look like Mick Jagger.

If you seriously think the Greens are turning Canadian politics upside down, let me ask you: Quickly, what's the name of the Green Party leader whose party holds three seats, and thus the balance of power, in New Brunswick?  You had to Google him, didn't you?  (It's David Coon.)

Do I actually have to explain that in order for a party to be considered populist, they have to represent a clear and present threat to the established order?  Or are we so naïve as a country that we actually believe that things in Canada will shift if we just elect a new bunch of no-name politicians who tell everyone that unlike everybody else, they're really, REALLY concerned about climate change?  Has nobody considered the possibility that under Prime Minister Elizabeth May, we will have a Green Party who isn't really Green, to go along with our Liberal Party that isn't liberal, a Conservative Party that isn't conservative, and a New Democratic Party that is neither New nor Democratic?

If we didn't already know that our politicians don't believe a word that comes out their mouths, but instead virtue signal this way and that in hopes of winning votes, then we could derive this understanding by noting the relative lack of so-called "bozo eruptions" from the Greens.  Populists say wacky things because they believe wacky things, and thus we can assume that if an alleged "populist" party is only slightly farther away from the Neutral Zone in their words or deeds, then it is either because they do not actually believe the wacky things they are accused of believing, or because they do not believe in those wacky things sufficiently to speak out and risk the consequences.

But then again, we are only in this completely stupid state of affairs where Elizabeth May has the Consensus clutching at their pearls because the almighty centrists cannot be bothered to stand up in defence of keeping the status quo either.  They believe that their own point of view is so self-evidently correct that being called upon to defend it is unnecessary, and that's why they're so incredibly bad at it when they're forced to do so during an election campaign.

And so, we have no need to fear change of any sort, because once again everyone's incompetence and dishonesty balances out perfectly!

Photo Credit: The Narwhal

Written by Josh Lieblein

The views, opinions and positions expressed by columnists and contributors are the author’s alone. They do not inherently or expressly reflect the views, opinions and/or positions of our publication.


Rationally-speaking, it's totally wrong for pundits and political journalists to read too much into the results of a single federal by-election.

Yet, it seems nobody can resist reading all sorts of things into the recent federal by-election in British Columbia's NanaimoLadysmith riding, the one which saw the Green Party score an impressive win.

Ever since then all the political chatter in this country is focusing on the sudden rise of what's being deemed a "Green Wave", which is not to be confused with the "Orange Wave" nor with the "Blue Wave".  (Sometimes you got to wonder if Canadian pundits are talking about politics or surfing!)

At any rate, the bottom line is smart political people are now openly wondering if the NDP and Liberals should be worried about losing progressive votes to an ascendant Green Party, a development that could potentially alter Canada's political balance of power.

And to be fair, it`s not just the recent by-election that has pundits seeing Green; the Green Party also did well in a recent Prince Edward Island provincial election (where it now forms the Official Opposition), it holds the balance of power in British Columbia, and it's also polling pretty well (relatively speaking) at the national level.

So it's easy to see why the Green Party is the flavor of the day.

But to fully understand this story we need to first ask these important questions: a) why is the Green Party gaining support?; b) can it maintain its apparent momentum? and c) who in the world would actually consider voting for the Green Party, given that its leader, Elizabeth May, has probably spent too much time standing under a solar panel, if you get my drift?

Anyway, let's first consider the "why?"

The easy answer, of course, is to suggest Canadians are embracing the Green Party because they suddenly care about environmental issues.

As a matter of fact, this was Prime Minister Justin Trudeau's reaction to the Green victory in Nanaimo-Ladysmith, which he said revealed that Canadians were "preoccupied" with the issue of climate change.

But I have a different interpretation.

In my view, the Green Party's recent success suggests Canada is witnessing the emergence of what might be called a "left-wing populist" movement.

In other words, I'd argue many progressive, left-wing voters in this country are getting fed up with mainstream political parties, (I'm looking at you federal Liberals) which they believe are too concerned with maintaining the capitalistic, elitist, status quo.

Hence, they're seeking a political alternative that's outside the mainstream, that's not tainted by any ties to the corporate world or to the ruling class elites or to globalized capitalism.

And the Green Party, with its quirky leader, its unorthodox policies, and its history of never holding power, perfectly fits the bill.

In short, the Green Party is about as far away from a serious political party as you can get.

And by the way, if I'm right about this, it speaks volumes about the weakness of the New Democratic Party under the leadership of Jagmeet Singh.

After all, it's the NDP, not the Greens, which should be the destination point for all left-wing populists, since it's Canada's only officially socialist party; its roots can even be traced to Western-based populism.

Yet, despite the SNC-Lavalin scandal, despite the Trans Mountain Pipeline fiasco, despite Trudeau's vacation trips to tropical island resorts, Singh has been unable to present himself as the left-wing, progressive alternative to the Liberal government.

This failure has created a void on the left, which the Green Party is filling.

So given all this, is it time to start talking about a new Green political force in Canada?

Well, that depends on whether or not Elizabeth May has the political savvy to take advantage of her new found fame.

That won't be easy, because, now that's she on the radar, her political opponents will come gunning for her.

For instance, if Singh has any leadership skill at all, he'll read on the writing on the wall and shift his party's gears to turn the NDP into more of a Bernie-Sanders-Jeremy-Corbyn-style, populist, socialist super-progressive party, in the hopes that he can snatch leftists away from the Greens.

What's more, you better believe Trudeau and the Liberals will do everything they can to derail the Green Express.

And I suspect their plan will be to remind leftists that they fear something even more than climate change: Andrew Scheer.

Basically, Trudeau will say something like, "a vote for the Greens is a really vote for Andrew Scheer and thus it's really a vote for Adolph Hitler."

So my point is, only time will tell if May can capitalize on her party's current success.

Not that it really matters.

If my theory is correct, and the Green Party is simply a vehicle of convenience for a growing left-wing populist surge, then it's not important whether this new force ultimately remains loyal to May or if it finds a home in the NDP or in the Liberal camp because at the end of the day, this newly emerging movement will have a strong voice somewhere.

And that could change Canadian politics more than any Green, Orange or Blue wave.

The views, opinions and positions expressed by columnists and contributors are the author’s alone. They do not inherently or expressly reflect the views, opinions and/or positions of our publication.