The weird thing is that the threat of climate change is dire enough that it doesn't need to be exaggerated. But that's exactly what the left is doing.
"The whole premise of the Green New Deal is that we're screwed on climate," says Alexandra Ocasio-Cortez. "What's the point of going to school if I won't have a future?" asks 11-year-old climate striker Sophia Mathur of Sudbury, Ontario. Corporations who won't do anything to stop climate change are doing so because they desire a Masque Of The Red Death scenario where the planet is purged of undesirables, mutter a host of continuously self-beclowning left-wing Canadian podcasters.
Climate change is happening, and it's going to keep on happening, and the effects are going to be pretty terrible, and there are going to need to be changes. This is clear. Is the world going to end? Are we going to go through a MaddAddam Trilogy scenario? PROBABLY NOT.
Maybe it was too much to expect that we could have a reasoned debate on climate change when every other political Hot Topic has devolved into a mostly pointless shouting match. And the right has obviously engaged in full on climate denialism for years. But as always: the left claims to hold a level of moral authority on this issue. It's why Catherine McKenna makes those execrable and awkward Twitter videos. It's why downtown Torontonians are so insufferably smug about public transit and cycling. It is, up to a point, why Trudeau tossed Jody Wilson-Raybould and Jane Philpott overboard- because after all, isn't Lavscam just a big and pointless distraction from the Liberal token efforts to "put a price on pollution"? Well, Andrew Cohen thinks so, anyway.
And, despite a few bumps in the road, this authoritarian and disingenuous strategy was working out pretty well for the Liberals. Thanks to a good deal of bumbling and the outright racism and conspirazoid thinking of their own loudest and dumbest members, the Yellow Vests were successfully written off as a bunch of yahoos with absolutely no valid concerns, and the Liberals managed to ensnare Andrew Scheer in the bargain as well. In Alberta, Jason Kenney is coating himself in crap and doing everything he can to make sure Notley gets rewarded for introducing her own carbon tax. Doug Ford can plaster as many stickers on as many gas pumps as he wants and it'll go over as well as Oily the Splot did back in 2008.
This is all happening because the left has won the debate on climate change and for the right, it's all over but the crying and everybody knows it. It took a few decades and a couple of Roland Emmerich movies, but here we are. You did it, guys. You finally got "social license" for your stupid tax that won't do a thing to stop climate change. There was no need for you to discard the high-and-mighty pretense and engage in base scaremongering. Except of course there was, because for the left, there is no victory unless there is total and complete domination. You can't declare victory, because that would mean there would be one less thing to have a phony war against.
What we are seeing, as the left takes this increasingly shrill and detached-from-reality tone, is a tacit acknowledgment on their part that the overwhelming weight of evidence isn't enough. Not when racist uncles across the country are still wondering why celebrities get to fly around the world to global warming conferences at holiday dinners. Did they look at Faith Goldy's fulminations on illegal immigration and say, "We can do better?" Because that's what it sounds like. At this rate we may soon start hearing that people in the global south are LITERALLY BEING REPLACED by climate change.
I would like to take comfort in the usual conservative maxim that eventually the left will take things too far and there will be a backlash, but, as we see here, there is no such thing as "too far". So, let us take another lesson from the sad case of the left-wingers who couldn't just take the W, and realize that when they talk of "evidence-based policy", they are only interested insofar as the evidence conforms with their own ideology.
Photo Credit: Jeff Burney, Loonie Politics
Written by Josh Lieblein